POST Online Media Lite Edition



 

Bundeskartellamt prohibits proposed merger between Loomis and Ziemann

Christian Fernsby |
The Bundeskartellamt has prohibited the acquisition of all shares of Germany’s second-largest cash handling service, Schallstadt-based Ziemann Sicherheit Holding GmbH, by Loomis AB, an internationally active Swedish cash handling service.

Article continues below



Topics: BUNDESKARTELLAMT    MERGER    LOOMIS    ZIEMANN   

The project would have considerably impeded effective competition in several very concentrated regional markets for cash handling services.

After the merger, Loomis/Ziemann and Prosegur would have basically been the only two companies active on the affected markets.

The remaining competitors would have been regionally active small and medium-sized companies with only very small market shares that are not considered potential suppliers by a large number of the customers affected by the merger.

Due to the reduction of the number of key competitors from three to two, there would have been a risk of higher costs for direct customers of these services– mostly in the areas of trade and banking– which would have indirectly resulted in higher costs for all consumers.

The commitments offered by the companies were not suitable to eliminate the Bundeskartellamt’s competition concerns.

The product market affected by the planned merger is the market for cash handling services.

It includes the transport of coins and banknotes to and from customers, cash processing in a Cash Center and the refilling and maintenance of ATMs including repairs and security, which are commissioned by banks.

However, it is not appropriate to further subdivide the product market into customer groups (trade, banks, public sector) because the clear majority of cash handlers offer their services to all customer groups.

The product market does not include security and guard services or the transport and logistics of valuables, which is third-party business.

Geographically, the markets are defined as regional.

As most of the customers operate exclusively locally or regionally, their demand for cash handling services continues to be met by regionally active companies, which supports the definition of regional markets.

Even customers who operate Germany-wide mostly commission either several regionally active cash handlers or companies like Prosegur and the parties to the merger that operate a cross-regional service network.

The supply side of the market also has a clear regional focus.

Providers of cash handling services are only able to offer their services within a certain radius of their location for cost reasons and due to working time regulations.

Nationwide cash handling services can thus only be provided by companies that have several locations over the country.

The Bundeskartellamt's investigations have confirmed the geographic market definition according to the radius around a location in which the target company achieves the largest part of its turnover, which had been established in previous proceedings.

Based on supply streams the Bundeskartellamt defined separate geographic markets for Bremen, Bielefeld/Munster, Bochum, Cologne, Koblenz and other areas and examined in detail the conditions of competition in these market areas.

However, in defining regional markets the Bundeskartellamt did not exclude the competition situation in neighbouring geographical markets from the competitive assessment of the merger project as in some cases the sales areas overlap depending on the tour planning and the geographic locations of the cash handling companies.

The investigations have shown that the competition situation would narrow down the number of key market players from three to two irrespective of the exact geographic market definition.

To confirm this result analyses of the service provision based on both the postcode and the location radius were carried out.

The competitive situation was also analysed across all of the regions affected by the merger in west and north-west Germany.

In this context the cash handlers’ competitive position is clearly influenced by both regional and supra-regional structural criteria.

The supply of cash handling services is highly concentrated in the various regions of Germany and shaped by a small group of suppliers that are either active on many regional markets or even nationwide.

The Spanish company Prosegur with its 31 subsidiaries all over Germany refers to itself as Germany’s market leader.

The Swedish Loomis Group only entered the German market by acquiring the cash and valuables handling business of Kötter Security in 2018.

It mainly offers cash handling services in west and north-west Germany.

Ziemann also offer cash handling services in many regions of Germany.

These three companies together achieve about 80 percent of the total turnover achieved with cash handling services in Germany.

The remaining 20 percent of the total turnover are achieved by more than 30 smaller cash handling service providers which focus on different regions in Germany.

Loomis’ acquisition of Ziemann, which is the subject of this case summary, is part of a continuous consolidation process1 and would be the second step of Loomis’ market entry into Germany that would add significant sales volumes as it would add locations and customers almost all over Germany to its existing resources and expand its geographic scope.

The Bundeskartellamt's assessment is that Loomis’ acquisition of Ziemann would eliminate the latter as an independent provider of cash handling services, which would considerably worsen market structures in the already very concentrated five regional markets of Bremen, Bielefeld/Munster, Bochum, Cologne and Koblenz.

The authority’s investigations have shown that the merger would significantly impede effective competition by changing the conditions of competition and the overall situation on the market for cash handling services, both on the regional and supraregional levels.

The merger would cause considerable unilateral effects.

The Bundeskartellamt did not base its prohibition decision on the Koblenz market as the minor market clause applies here2 .

The merger would not only eliminate an important competitor in the affected markets, it would also weaken competitive pressure on Germany’s market leader and close competitor Prosegur, because the latter would lose a serious competitor and its customers would have one significant option less to choose from.

The affected markets would see the number of key suppliers reduced from three to two.

After the merger the two leading suppliers would cover approximately 80 percent of the market volume.

The combined market share lead of these companies over their regional competitors in the affected regional markets is between nearly 60 to over 85 percent.

Their regional competitors are not able to effectively limit Loomis/Ziemann’s and Prosegur’s competitive scope of action.

The investigations have shown that customers already have very few options to switch providers, even without the merger, and that the business relationships are very stable.

There is little or no competition on prices or terms and conditions.

In addition, customers often make no effort to discipline the market leader through strategic procurement behaviour.

The Bundeskartellamt estimates that the post-merger incentives for price increases or other deteriorations in supply would be high during the merger control forecast period, particularly as there were considerable price increases even before the merger.

These anti-competitive effects can be expected regardless of whether Loomis became the market leader in the affected regional markets after the merger or merely closed the gap on market leader Prosegur.

It is to be expected that post-merger the scope of competitive action of the two leading providers of cash handling services, Loomis/Ziemann and Prosegur, would not be sufficiently controlled by the remaining small and medium-sized competitors in the market.

Rather, the Bundeskartellamt’s assessment is that the merger would have increased the two leading providers’ opportunities for ousting their remaining smaller competitors from the market.

Loomis and Ziemann repeatedly offered commitments in response to the Bundeskartellamt’s statement of objections which involved selling customer contracts and the pertaining infrastructure in the respective regional markets to not more than one independent competitor each.

According to the final version of their commitments the volume of these customer contracts would have balanced the growth resulting from the acquisition to a large extent in terms of figures.

This would in theory have given the competitor acquiring the contracts the potential to outweigh the decreased competitive pressure.

However, it was not sufficiently likely that the affected customers would actually and permanently switch to the corresponding acquirer of their contracts.

Market tests have shown that customers and competitors shared a mostly critical view of the commitments and confirmed the Bundeskartellamt’s concerns.

Their statements raised the concern that a significant part of the surveyed customers would generally not be willing to switch to another cash handling service.

Many of those customers generally willing to switch their service provider said they would switch at most to the market leader Prosegur.

However, the Bundeskartellamt assessed that customers switching to Prosegur would be just as detrimental for competition.

For this reason, the commitments offered would not have been sufficient to prevent the significant impediment to effective competition that was to be expected as a consequence of the merger.


What to read next

Loomis probes possible money laundering
Bundeskartellamt allows EDEKA to acquire Handelshof
Amazon extends sellers' rights after pressure from Bundeskartellamt

Tracking areas of severe thunderstorms, excessive rainfall, and excessive heat in U.S.

 
The relentlessly active spring weather pattern is set to continue through the holiday weekend as two separate systems are anticipated to be responsible for numerous showers and thunderstorms across the middle of the nation.
 
 

Latest

U.S. drillers cut oil and gas rigs to 600
North Carolina Governor to lead economic development trip in Europe
Google expanding connectivity in Africa with Umoja
Bentley opens workshop in Bulgaria

NEWS

Italy: EPPO seizes assets in investigation into €650 000 fraud involving agricultural funds

Italy draws up emergency plans for Campi Flegrei super volcano
New fire at Novo Nordisk, this time at headquarters
Iran releases first investigation report on President Raisi's helicopter crash
Another round of heavy rainfall and severe storms impacting southern U.S.
French growers protest Moroccan imports
 

BUSINESS

U.S oil and gas rigs count increased by 1 to 604

NYCEDC supporting major battery energy storage project in New York City
U.S. drillers cut oil and gas rigs to 603
Number of U.S. oil and natural gas rigs down
U.S. added 2 oil rigs
U.S. oil rig count up by 5 to 511
 

Trending Now

U.S. drillers cut oil and gas rigs to 600

Belgium second EU country to authorise bluetongue vaccine

Potentially habitable 'exo-Venus' with Earth-like temperature discovered

Iran releases first investigation report on President Raisi's helicopter crash


POLITICS

Poland signs $960m deal for U.S. radar balloons

Governor Moore announces renewal and expansion of economic MoU with South Australia
Governor Parson to embark on trade mission to Italy to promote Missouri as ideal business location
Governor Abbott hosts Kosovo President Osmani
Australian government to set up inquiry to examine impact of social media
Hungary and China sign 19 cooperation agreements during Xi's visit
 

Today We Recommend

Poland signs $960m deal for U.S. radar balloons


Highlights 

Georgia: First Quality in Macon to create 600 new jobs

Afreximbank delivers strong Q1 results

Ralph Lauren Q4 earnings per diluted share $1.38


COMPANIES

Georgia: First Quality in Macon to create 600 new jobs

Hollywood makeup brand Ben Nye files for bankruptcy as it faces talc cancer lawsuits
SEG Solar and Grand Batang City sign land utilization deal for Southeast Asia's largest PV industrial park
Bulgaria demands €400 million from Gazprom for suspended gas supplies
BlueHalo to expand operations, adding 200 new jobs in Maryland
Maersk speeds up supply chains in Europe with new Cross Dock facility
 

CAREERS

BioMar announces changes in management in Ecuador

CLG appoints managing director for Equatorial Guinea
Mark Gazit appointed executive chairman of N.E.W.S.
IFCO appoints Sebastian Grams as chief digital officer
Marlabs appoints Arun Mukunda as CRO
AfdB names Ambassador Jalel Trabelsi as Special Envoy for Middle East and North Africa and Gulf region
 

ECONOMY

Eurozone reports modest Q1 GDP growth, stable annual inflation

Italy sees faster economic growth in Q1
Slovenia's economy expected to grow 0.9 pct in Q1
Italy faces deficit infringement procedure
Real GDP increased in all 50 U.S. states
Inflation continues to decline in Germany
 

EARNINGS

Macy's Q1 diluted earnings per share $0.22

Afreximbank delivers strong Q1 results
Ralph Lauren Q4 earnings per diluted share $1.38
Dubai World Trade Centre economic output surges to $4.98 billion in 2023
Dole Q1 revenue $2.1 billion
Hapag-Lloyd Q1 EBITDA $942 million
 

OP-ED

Micromanaging is the worst enemy of efficiency and teamwork

Niger set to monetize massive gas reserves through Saharan natural gas pipeline
Putting the brakes on EV folly that choked the market
Oil discovery in Kavango Basin may mean huge benefits for Namibians
Cape Town and Dubai battle over Africa's energy future
Is America going to lose its superpower status?
 

AGRIFISH

Belgium second EU country to authorise bluetongue vaccine

UK government unveils major package of farming and food sector support
Governor Desantis signs legislation to keep lab-grown meat out of Florida
Tanzania, Kenya resolve poultry export dispute
FAO Food Price Index rises in March
Australia grants license for GM bananas amid Fusarium Wilt TR4 concerns
 

LEADERSHIP

Study finds workers misjudge wage markets

Some organizations may need to expand their hierarchical structures earlier than others
Study finds there's right way and wrong way to deliver negative feedback in workplace
Allyship is critical and its needs appreciation
Generating 'buzz' about new products can influence their success
Hiring 'problem directors' can knock up to 64% off firm's value
 

CRIME

EU Commission fines Mondelēz €337.5 million for cross-border trade restrictions

HSBC pays penalties for alleged breaches of Consumer Data Right rules
Sanofi to settle thousands of Zantac cancer lawsuits
Former asset manager and board member of Geneva private bank referred to Swiss Federal Criminal Court
South Africa: SAP ordered to pay SIU $26m over 'invalid' Eskom contracts
Former Steinhoff director appears in court for $1.1b fraud, racketeering
 

Magazine

TRAVEL

Morocco’s first Radisson branded hotel opens in Casablanca

Buna channels, an unreal and beautiful part of Bosnia and Herzegovina
JW Marriott unveils Mindful Haven with opening of JW Marriott Hotel Nairobi
Sotheby's Sports Week returns with fantastic artifacts
Red Roof properties open in Michigan
Treyam, your premier lagoon destination in Saudi Arabia
 

SEA, LAND, AIR

2025 Chevrolet Equinox stands apart with fresh looks and capability

Hill Helicopters HX50, luxury in the sky
Opel Movano becomes fully equipped camper van
Porsche Panamera, new hybrid variants
Dodge Charger, 670 horsepower of electric
Pagani Huayra R Evo, 900 hp from 770 Nm
 

DESIGN

Cold night, hot fire pit, cool entertainment

Embellish your home with PVC panels
You'll have to hurry if you want one of 20 new Louis Vuitton watches
Luxury duvet looks good, fells good and keeps you healthy
Vacheron Constantin, watches for life and more
Schüller kitchens, where functionality marries design
 

GADGETS

reMarkable 2, monochrome tablet for your thoughts and your eyes

OnePlus Ace 3V, first with Snapdragon 7 Plus Gen 3
ASUS Zenfone 11 Ultra, flagship with a reason
Samsung Galaxy S24 is photography powerhouse
Casette tapes are making a big comeback, and so are portable players
Neumann TLM 103, standard microphone for both voice and music
 

HEALTH

UK: People with HIV can now donate eggs or sperm to start family

EU health watchdog urges vaccinations to stem surge in Whooping Cough cases
Brazil resumes insulin production after two decades
India launches first home-grown gene therapy for cancer
UK scientists win funding for 'cancer detecting' Lollipops
State to cover rare disease treatment costs in Bulgaria
 

MEANTIME

Potentially habitable 'exo-Venus' with Earth-like temperature discovered

Rare species of wild bees discovered in Berlin
SLAC completes construction of largest digital camera ever built for astronomy
Solar eclipse next week in U.S., Mexico and Canada
Gravitational waves may have made human life possible
Astronomers unveil strong magnetic fields spiraling at the edge of Milky Way's central black hole