POST Online Media Lite Edition



 

How awards, recognition decrease inventors' creativity

Christian Fernsby |
New research from Olin Business School at Washington University in St. Louis, published in the Journal of Applied Psychology, has identified one reason why some first-time producers struggle to repeat their initial creative productions while others go on to continually produce creative works.

Article continues below




Markus Baer, professor of organizational behavior at Olin, and Dirk Deichmann, of the Rotterdam School of Management in the Netherlands, discovered that recognizing first-time producers of successful novel ideas with an award or recognition can significantly decrease the likelihood that they will produce future creative work.

"In our study, we found that people who develop novel ideas and receive rewards for them start to see themselves primarily as a 'creative person,'" Baer said.

"This newfound identity, which is special and rare, is then in need of protection. Essentially, once a person is in the creative limelight, stepping out of it—by producing a novel idea that disappoints or pales in comparison to earlier work—is threatening and to be avoided. One way to do so is to stop producing altogether. You cannot compromise your identity and reputation when you do not produce anything new."

In other words, fear of failure the second time around can cause producers to avoid taking risks that would threaten their creative identity.

"Harper Lee is a perfect example of this phenomenon," Baer said. "Her first book, 'To Kill a Mockingbird,' is one of the bestselling and most acclaimed American novels of all time. Yet she didn't publish again until 55 years later. And her second book, 'Go Set a Watchman,' written in the mid-1950s, is considered to be a first draft of her legendary one hit wonder."

To study the effect receiving an award or recognition had on first-time producers, Baer and Deichmann first conducted an archival study of 224 first-time cookbook authors in the United Kingdom. According to the study authors, the cookbook market is an ideal context to examine sustained creativity because cookbooks are creative works and a labor of love. From this sample, they found only about 50% of first-time cookbook authors went on to produce a second cookbook. Interestingly, they also discovered that the more novel the initial cookbook was, the less likely the author was to produce a second cookbook.

Next, Baer and Deichmann conducted an experiment with business school students. Participants were asked to develop a concept for a potential cookbook. Half of the participants were told that their idea was "highly original and novel," while the other half were told their idea was "very solid and traditional." A subgroup of participants was also told that their ideas were "among the ideas most likely to make a big splash in the food community."

Finally, participants had the option to develop a second cookbook concept or to build upon their original idea with a marketing plan. The experiment showed that when people produce a highly novel, award-winning idea, right out of the gate, they're less likely to produce a follow-up idea.

A second experiment built upon the original and allowed the authors to more precisely pinpoint the psychological mechanisms at play. In the two experimental studies, the percentage of first-time producers who decided to develop a second idea, as opposed to exploiting the first idea, was 21 and 34, respectively.

"Participants experienced a greater threat to their creative identity when producers of award-winning, novel work were confronted with the possibility of having to continue on their creative journey by having to produce original work yet again," the authors concluded.

Creativity is most likely to blossom in environments where producers are motivated primarily by the challenge and meaning of the work itself—i.e., the problem they are trying to solve—and have some creativity-specific skills, such as associating or combining ideas from different knowledge domains, Baer said.

Previous research has focused on the benefits of awards, but Baer and Deichmann found that winning an award can, paradoxically, temper the creativity of producers because it introduces an extra layer of stress to the creative environment.

"Awards are only bad for people producing novel stuff because they make the creative identity of such people salient, causing them to feel threatened by the prospect of compromising this identity with mediocre work," he said.


What to read next

When hiring, don't forget: Creativity is not just for the young
You are creative
Creative staff lead to satisfied customers

U.S.: Widespread showers and thunderstorms through midweek

 
Monsoonal moisture will continue to draw northward from the Southwest and pool with moisture from the Gulf of Mexico over the central U.S. along a sprawling, slow-moving frontal boundary.
 
 

Latest

Riva Wind and Arizona sail from Ukraine with 105,000 tons of grain
300 soldiers, scuba divers join rescue efforts to try to save trapped Mexican miners
New York: Start of construction on $75 million rehabilitation of public housing in Ithaca
Flooding hampers efforts to reach trapped miners in Mexico

NEWS

First Ukraine ship under grain deal will not dock in Lebanon on time

U.S.: Heat and flood threats this weekend
New York: Direct train service to Great New York State Fair
Illinois day care worker positive for monkeypox, children tested for virus
Lightning strike causes major fire at Cuban fuel depot
France's drought leaves towns short of drinking water
 

BUSINESS

Monthly minimum wage in Chile $440

Gaza power plant shuts down over lack of fuel
Pakistan plans long term LNG purchase
Japan lends over 300 mln USD to Cambodia for Sihanoukville deep-sea port expansion
Ukraine welcomes first foreign ship since war began
Suez Canal records all-time highest daily traffic
 

Trending Now

Monthly minimum wage in Chile $440

Take it or leave it: Pakistan offers $390/ton for Russian wheat

Batten disease, a group of fatal genetic disorders

Guardia di Financa finds unregistered foreign company operating in e-commerce


POLITICS

Iran not to give up on its water share rights

Italy grants Ukraine EUR 200 mln preferential loan for teachers' salaries
Putin, Erdogan agree to switch to ruble payments for Russian gas
China pushing world to climate disaster, cuts some ties with U.S.
Florida Governor DeSantis suspends State Attorney over abortion law
Italy unveils 17-bln-euro aid package to combat inflation, drought
 

Today We Recommend

Canada to temporarily ban handgun import


Highlights 

Goodyear Q2 net income more than doubles

Ritchie Bros. Q2 revenue increased 22%

APA acquires oil producing assets in West Texas for $505m


COMPANIES

Masdar signs agreement with Tanzania’s TANESCO to develop 2 GW renewable energy capacity

Zero emission electric portable air compressors for Chinese mines
Kuwait's Agility completes £763 million acquisition of Menzies Aviation
Delta adding nonstop flights from Atlanta to Cape Town and Los Angeles to Tahiti
Lufthansa ground staff agree pay deal after strike
Russia allows parallel imports of some L'Oreal brands
 

CAREERS

Horizon Bancorp appoints Thomas M. Prame as president

Encora appoints Deepak Bhandari as EVP, head of corporate development
Firmenich: Maurizio Clementi interim president of taste and beyond division
Joyce Farms appoints two new leaders
Shore Bancshares appoints Esther A. Streete as director
Liberty Group Construction Services appoints Jeffrey VanderVorst as EVP
 

ECONOMY

Vietnamese economy likely to grow 10% in Q3

Canada's exports rise in June
Minnesota received AAA rating from Moody's for first time in nearly 20 years
Half of U.S. mortgaged homes now considered equity-rich
U.S. factory orders jump much more than expected
Oklahoma Governor Stitt achieves historic state savings of $2.8 billion
 

EARNINGS

Goodyear Q2 net income more than doubles

Ritchie Bros. Q2 revenue increased 22%
MOL Q2 EBITDA $1.347bn
SWISS posts H1 operating profit
Wayfair Q2 net revenue decreased $573 million
Security Bancorp Q2 net income increases to $744,000
 

OP-ED

Micromanaging is the worst enemy of efficiency and teamwork

Niger set to monetize massive gas reserves through Saharan natural gas pipeline
Putting the brakes on EV folly that choked the market
Oil discovery in Kavango Basin may mean huge benefits for Namibians
Cape Town and Dubai battle over Africa's energy future
Is America going to lose its superpower status?
 

AGRIFISH

Take it or leave it: Pakistan offers $390/ton for Russian wheat

Commission approves €110 million Austrian scheme to support agricultural producers
Japan farm exports in H1 hit record
Hong Kong suspends import of poultry meat and products from areas in UK
Hong Kong suspends import of poultry meat and products from Magadan Oblast in Russia
British Columbia and Ontario calls out unfair U.S. duties on softwood lumber
 

LEADERSHIP

62% of consumers will stop buying from brands that compromise products to cut costs

Companies must invest to avoid supply chain scandal or pay the price in lost consumers
How awards, recognition decrease inventors' creativity
Keeping employees is harder than ever. And we don't have good news
How much is 'great resignation' costing companies?
New theory of decision-making seeks to explain why humans don't make optimal choices
 

CRIME

Guardia di Financa finds unregistered foreign company operating in e-commerce

Iowa AG sues tobacco companies over $133 million in withheld payments
AG Bonta announces $15.5 million judgment against Rent-A-Center
Illinois AG Raoul announces agreement with former opioid maker Allergan
AG Shapiro secures preliminary agreement with Teva for $4.25 billion
SEC charges eleven individuals in $300 million crypto pyramid scheme
 

Magazine

TRAVEL

Pullman Doha West Bay Hotel opens in Qatar

DoubleTree by Hilton hotel opens in Malaysia
Great Dorset Chilli Festival, the hottest festival in UK
Selina Serenity Rawai Phuket Hotel opens in Thailand
254 Room W Toronto Hotel opens
Summer of music, Summer Meltdown in Washington state
 

SEA, LAND, AIR

Porsche unveils newest generation of 911 GT3 R

2023 Subaru Crosstrek sells like hotcakes
New Mercedes‑Benz GLC, at home on any terrain
GMC unleashes new 2023 Sierra 1500 AT4X AEV Edition
First BMW M3 Touring presented
Southern Wind Power of 2, just for you and ocean ahead
 

DESIGN

Nobody's Child, everybody's favorite

Freddy WR.UP, pants that hug you in all the right places
Stylishly luxurious house design
Great design ideas that might not work for you
Garden mirrors, explore new views of your garden
Unusual and highly functional lamps
 

GADGETS

Shure MV7 professional dynamic microphone now available in new limited-edition color

Forget streaming services, use McIntosh MR89 to enjoy AM/FM music
Infinix NOTE 12 PRO, first smartphone powered by MediaTek Helio G99
MW75 active noise-cancelling headphones, variety of new features
Parasound JC 1+ mono power amplifier by John Curl, pure delight
Cambridge Audio SX80, stylish loudspeakers for any room
 

HEALTH

At least 12 deaths reported in cholera outbreak in Afghanistan's Jawzjan

Batten disease, a group of fatal genetic disorders
German government supports development of nasal COVID-19 vaccine
Cases of West Nile virus on the rise in Italy
U.S. declares monkeypox public health emergency
South Africa reports first death causally linked to COVID vaccine
 

MEANTIME

South Korea launches first lunar orbiter

Bantu speakers crossed through Central African Rainforest 4,000 years ago, changed everything
Webb telescope captures colorful Cartwheel Galaxy
Sadiq Khan launched £3.1m tree planting package to combat climate change
First European woman walks in space
Hubble images complex galactic trio