POST Online Media Lite Edition



 

Proxy advisers have inherent incentive to create controversy, study shows

Christian Fernsby |
When an institutional investor uses recommendations from a proxy adviser to cast a vote on shareholder issues, they may want to proceed with caution.

Article continues below




Professional proxy advisory firms have an incentive to publicly recommend a vote contrary to what company management proposes, according to a new study by Nadya Malenko and Andrey Malenko, associate professors of finance at the University of Michigan's Ross School of Business.

That doesn't necessarily mean the advisers make misleading recommendations, but it does suggest investors should be aware of the situation, they argue.

Proxy advisers are firms that analyze proposals to be voted on by a company's shareholders, and then sell their analysis to the shareholders. Although they have existed since the 1980s, they have become more prominent lately due to the rise of institutional investors, which have large portfolios and need the proxy advisers' services.

At the same time, proposals to be voted on have become more complex, Nadya Malenko says.

The detailed research reports that proxy advisers provide to their clients are private, but their bottom-line recommendations on how to vote often become public knowledge through the media.

In earlier research, Nadya Malenko found proxy advisers are directly responsible for moving an average of 25% of the votes on proposals related to executive compensation. Whether this strong influence should be a concern depends on the quality of proxy advisers' advice, she says.

"If they're providing informative research and recommendations, that's great because they are making voters more informed. But if the quality of advice is poor, then this influence is concerning," she said.

The Malenkos' paper focuses on a fundamental conflict: Advisers' research reports are more valuable to the shareholders if the outcome of the vote is uncertain. Therefore, proxy advisers have an incentive to make recommendations that are "controversial" and go against what the company proposes, Nadya Malenko says.

"If we think about their business model, they are sellers of information. They get their profits from selling their research to shareholders," she said. "By biasing their recommendations against the more likely alternative, proxy advisers give shareholders more incentives to invest in information."

She says the new findings do not necessarily mean that advisory firms actually make bad recommendations in practice.

"This is a theory paper; it highlights that this problem, this fundamental conflict of interest, exists," she said. What we cannot say is whether this is really driving recommendations. We hope the next step for empirical research will be to investigate that."

Meanwhile, however, the research could lead to reforms to address the conflict of interest.

"We hope our paper will create useful conversation," Nadya Malenko said. "One possible policy implication is to not allow these public recommendations. The proxy advisers' report could offer all the analysis, but would not conclude with a proscriptive recommendation to vote yes or no. It's not necessarily an optimal solution, but under certain circumstances it could help."

The research is available as a working paper online in the SSRN Electronic Journal.


What to read next

CEO personality traits play role in incentive pay, compensation
Give your team an unexpected reward and watch them flourish
Project managers do not always give accurate information to the boss

U.S.: Locally heavy rain and snow

 
A slow-moving front draped across the south-central portion of the CONUS continues to focus much of the active weather over the CONUS, and will continue to do for the next several days.
 
 

Latest

Epiphone announced seven Adam Jones Art Collection Les Paul Custom models
Canada’s first all-electric vehicle manufacturing facility opens in Ontario
Walmart to pay Massachusetts $500,000 as part of alleged drug pricing violations
Canon Europe promotes Hiro Imamura to EVP, digital printing & solutions

NEWS

Croatian MiG-21 crashed, both pilots survived

EPPO’s Paris office investigates French former MEP and assistant on suspicion of fictitious employment
Virginity testing, virginity certification and hymen reconstruction surgery to be criminalised in Sweden
UK rail walkouts confirmed over Christmas period
Russian state bank VTB hit by DDoS attack
6.2 magnitude earthquake jolts western Indonesia
 

BUSINESS

Deal on new law to ensure products causing deforestation are not sold in EU

NHS plans to return retired and partially retired staff to work
Germany approves tax benefits for small solar installations
Payday loans market to reach $6.8 billion
U.S. preliminarily finds some companies circumventing solar tariffs
Switzerland watchdog investigates labour market in banking sector
 

Trending Now

Asuncion, Mother of Cities and Paraguay’s center of culture, music and shopping

Epiphone announced seven Adam Jones Art Collection Les Paul Custom models

Walmart to pay Massachusetts $500,000 as part of alleged drug pricing violations

Canon Europe promotes Hiro Imamura to EVP, digital printing & solutions


POLITICS

Thousand of Moldova's households to get higher compensations when paying bills

FM: Hungary received exemption from using oil price cap
Commission approves €26.3 million Finnish measure to support SEVO in construction of hydroelectric pump storage
Five Polish regions to get €3.85 billion for just transition toward climate neutral economy
Jordan, Norway to partner on renewable energy, green hydrogen
Colorado submits Canadian drug importation plan to FDA
 

Today We Recommend

Payday loans market to reach $6.8 billion


Highlights 

Asda targets 300 new convenience stores creating 10,000 jobs in UK

Becker Robotic Equipment will create 137 new jobs in Cherokee County, Georgia

Iran’s shrimp exports to Russia up by 350% this year


COMPANIES

Asda targets 300 new convenience stores creating 10,000 jobs in UK

Illumina gets EU antitrust charge sheet to unwind Grail acquisition swiftly
Owens Corning completes sale of Russian operations
Milence charging network accelerates Europe's shift to fossil-free road transport
TotalEnergies to supply sustainable aviation fuel to Air France-KLM
Becker Robotic Equipment will create 137 new jobs in Cherokee County, Georgia
 

CAREERS

BioMar appoints Andrew Campbell as CEO for AQ1

Roche appoints Brad Moore as CEO of Roche Diagnostics North America
Duke Energy chief operating officer Dhiaa Jamil to retire
MSC Industrial Supply elects Rahquel Purcell as director
Boeing appoints Brendan Nelson as Boeing International
Totally appoints John McMullan as medical director
 

ECONOMY

Germany factory orders recover on foreign demand

South Africa's Q3 GDP grows 1.6%
World Bank hikes Philippines' 2022 GDP forecast to 7.2 pct
CBI severely downgrades UK growth forecast
Japan services PMI continued to expand in November
Italy: GDP growth loses momentum in Q3
 

EARNINGS

AutoZone Q1 net income decreased to $539.32 million

Genesco Q3 2023 GAAP earnings $1.66
Kirkland's Q3 sales $131.0 million
Cracker Barrel Old Country Store Q1 2023 revenue $839.5 million
Malvern Bancorp Q4 net income $2.6 million
Big Lots Q3 loss $4.33 million
 

OP-ED

Micromanaging is the worst enemy of efficiency and teamwork

Niger set to monetize massive gas reserves through Saharan natural gas pipeline
Putting the brakes on EV folly that choked the market
Oil discovery in Kavango Basin may mean huge benefits for Namibians
Cape Town and Dubai battle over Africa's energy future
Is America going to lose its superpower status?
 

AGRIFISH

Rospotrebnadzor: Swine flu reported in 74 Russian regions

Hong Kong Customs detects suspected frozen meat smuggling case involving cargo vessel
First direct train from Laos to China arrives with 543 tons of fruit
Vets cull 15,000 ducks in Czech Republic over bird flu outbreak
Hong Kong suspends poultry meat and products import from areas in Canada
China interested in importing Kazakh agricultural products
 

LEADERSHIP

Only 32% of employees believe their pay is fair

Corporate duty waivers limit organic company growth and innovation
Women buy from women, men buy from women and men
How employee opinion impacts CEO dismissal
Keeping it in family can be good news when it comes to CEOs
Over a third of office workers are hybrid 'misfits'
 

CRIME

AT&T settles SEC charge of selectively disclosing material information to Wall St. analysts

Hertz to pay $168 mln to settle over 95% of wrongful theft report claims
Glencore to pay Republic of Congo $180 mln over alleged corruption claims
Fraudsters target water infrastructure projects, OLAF closes several cases
Rhode Island man to pay more than $2.8 million in restitution for virtual currency fraud
Switzerland fines ABB $4.3 mn over South Africa bribery
 

Magazine

TRAVEL

Cambria Hotels opens in Minneapolis

All aboard the Heathrow Festive Express
Asuncion, Mother of Cities and Paraguay’s center of culture, music and shopping
"Pets with Love" Dog Adoption Carnival 2022 to be held in Hong Kong
Weather-resistant ArtWalk Downtown Billings, Montana
Dual branded Courtyard and Residence Inn by Marriott Hotel opens in Montreal
 

SEA, LAND, AIR

Lamborghini Huracán Sterrato, first super sports car for any terrain

New colorful Porsche 718 Style Edition models
2023 Toyota Prius Prime, solar panel roof and reliability
Volvo EX90, a car with updates
Cessna Citation CJ4 Gen2 jet, pursue your business goals while enjoying journey
GMC first Sierra EV marks turning point
 

DESIGN

Patchwork carpets, vintage Persian carpets made with unparalleled skill

Real life wallpapers, perfectly executed
A. Lange & Söhne, men's watches with true Saxonian DNA
Nella Vetrina, luxurious Italian designers bathroom vanities and furniture
Karastan rugs, durable and beautiful
Leather bags for every occasion and every life style
 

GADGETS

ASUS launches ExpertBook B9 for executives

Take Elektor Fortissimo and make your own high-end amplifier
RangeXTD, a Wi-Fi extender that actually works
Monitor II A.N.C. headphones, iconic Marshall sound
Zebra TC15, a clever mix of a mobile phone and a computer for business use
Bathroom speakers will make your relaxing even better
 

HEALTH

Justice Department secures agreement with Alabama Medicaid to remove unlawful sobriety mandate for health care access

Pfizer and BioNTech apply for FDA authorization for Omicron-retooled vaccine booster in kids under 5
Cornwall first area in England to trial NHS Digital Health Check
Huge rise of scarlet fever cases in UK, 6 kids dead of Strep A
Neglecting COVID this year created perfect conditions for deadly new variant
EMA recommends withdrawal of pholcodine medicines from EU market
 

MEANTIME

Mars is more active than previously thought

James Webb telescope produces an unparalleled view of the ghostly light in galaxy clusters
China's two meteorological satellites put into operation
Lagoon dries up as drought grips Peru
Mysteriously bright flash is black hole jet pointing straight toward Earth
Researchers discover Egypt's oldest tomb oriented to winter solstice