POST Online Media Lite Edition


Secret plastic waste trade agreement between Canada and USA illegal, says group

Christian Fernsby |
We are writing to express our serious concerns regarding the fact that five weeks ago the Canadian government, in a secretive, non transparent manner, signed a Bilateral Arrangement with the United States regarding the import and export of plastic wastes, RightOnCanada and Basel Action Network group wrote to Jonathan Wilkinson, Minister.

Article continues below

"In addition to the secretive manner in which the Agreement was negotiated, we are concerned that in signing the Agreement Canada will be in violation of its legal obligations under the Basel Convention when the Convention's plastic wastes provisions come into effect on January 1, 2021.

"The Canadian government has expressed its desire to ratify the Basel Convention amendments including the new listings of contaminated and difficult to recycle plastic waste before the amendments come into effect on January 1.

"These amendments require that Canada obtain Prior Informed Consent from any Basel Party to which Canada wishes to export plastic wastes that are listed in the Basel Convention and forbids trading such waste with no parties.

"The United States is not a Party to the Basel Convention and is therefore not bound by these requirements.

"Parties such as Canada are prohibited from trading hazardous or other wastes with non-Parties.

"However, Article 11 of the Convention allows Parties such as Canada an exception to this rule if they sign Bilateral Agreements with non-Parties such as the United States.

"Any country exercising the Article 11 exception is legally obliged under Article 11 to ensure that "these agreements or arrangements shall stipulate provisions which are not less environmentally sound than those provided for by the Convention" and "must not derogate from the environmentally sound management of hazardous wastes and other wastes as required under the Convention." The agreement signed by Canada is reported to maintain the status quo and allow a free trade in these newly listed plastic wastes, and thus once the new Basel Convention amendments on plastic wastes enter into force, the Canadian agreement with the U.S. will derogate dramatically from the provisions of the Convention.

"The bilateral agreement fails to meet the test of providing an equivalent level of control (no control v. prior informed consent) and thus fails to ensure its provisions are not less environmentally sound than those required by Article 11 of the Convention.

"We are deeply concerned that the Canada-United States Arrangement on export of plastic wastes, which Canada initiated and signed on October 26, 2020, thus does not comply with the Basel Convention and further sends a message to the world that Canada is willing to violate international law and wants the environmental trade rules they helped negotiate to apply to others but not to themselves or their trading partners.

"The United States government invited non governmental organisations to participate in a briefing "on the recently signed Arrangement Between the Government of the United States of America and the Government of Canada concerning the Environmentally Sound Management of Non-Hazardous Waste and Scrap subject to Transboundary Movement.” The text of the Arrangement was not presented at that meeting, but was declared to be an Article 11 arrangement that will preserve the current free trade in plastic waste and scrap of all kinds even after the entry into force of the Plastic Waste Amendments to the Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movement of Hazardous Wastes and Their Disposal.

"At that meeting, U.S. government officials also stated that the Arrangement was not legally binding.

"It is impossible to understand how on the one hand it can be said to meet the Article 11 requirements of the Basel Convention, which is legally binding on Canada, and at the same time not be a legally binding document.

"It also appears that there are no requirements in the Arrangement that the United States not export to developing countries the plastic wastes that it imports from Canada unless it first obtains the Prior Informed Consent of the importing developing country.

"We are concerned that the Bilateral Arrangement appears not to comply with the Basel Convention.

"This situation will open a loophole whereby Canada can export plastic wastes to the US and these plastic wastes can then by re-exported by the United States to developing countries without complying with the Basel Convention and its new Amendments.

"Such a loophole does not adhere to the intent and purpose of the Amendments and the Convention itself.

"Such an agreement, would violate Canada’s international legal obligations and would gravely undermine the Basel Convention.

"We note that at a Parliamentary Committee hearing on a private member's bill regarding export of plastic wastes (Bill C-204) on October 30, 2020, your Parliamentary Secretary,Terry Duguid, speaking on your behalf, stated: "The majority of Canada’s trade in plastic waste is with the United States." While speaking about Canada's export of plastic wastes to the United States, Mr.

"Duguid failed to disclose that Canada had just four days earlier signed an important Bilateral Arrangement with the United States regarding export of plastic wastes, many of which can be easily re-exported to third countries by U.S. waste brokers.

"We consider this to be troubling on its face but also an example of an extreme lack of transparency.

"We request that:

"The government make the Bilateral Agreement between Canada and the United

tates public;

"The government complete the ratification of the the Basel Convention Plastic Waste amendments and, if has not, state when it intends to do so;

"The Bilateral Arrangement be changed to require prior informed consent for all export of plastic waste between Canada and the United States and ensure it provides an equivalent level of control as the Basel Convention, in particular a strict prohibition of re-export of those waste transferred from Canada.

"That Canada, take steps to ensure that plastic wastes leaving Canada and entering the U.S. will not be able to be exported to third countries."

Others are David Azoulay, Managing Attorney, Geneva Office; Director, Environmental Health Program, CIEL - Centre for International Environmental Law Dr. Tadesse Amera and Pamela Miller, Co-Chairs, IPEN Beatrice Beatrice Olivastri, CEO, Friends of the Earth Olga Speranskaya, HEJSupport Co-Director Denise Patel, U.S. Program Coordinator, Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives GAIA Tim Grabiel, environmental investigation agency Jan Dell, Founder, The Last Beach Cleanup Julia Cohen, Managing Director, Plastic Pollution Coalition Jennie Romer, Esq., Legal Associate, Plastic Pollution Initiative, Surfrider Foundation.

What to read next

China reveals plan to cut plastic use by 2025
US only OECD country objects new rules to better control exports of contaminated plastic waste
Hong Kong: Enhanced waste plastics import and export control to take effect January 1, 2021

U.S.: Arctic front slides southward

A wave of low pressure over the Middle Mississippi Valley will move northeastward to off Northern New England Coast by Monday evening.


Italian Prime Minister in Libya to conclude $8 billion gas deal
Curved sofas, elegant and gentle
Record rainfall overnight in Auckland causes massive flooding
New swine fever outbreak confirmed in Gauteng, South Africa


Drug trafficking network in Italy and Albania taken down

Japan launches intelligence satellite to join fleet in orbit
U.S. designates former President of Panama Martinelli for involvement in significant corruption
French workers go on 48-hour strike over pension reform proposal
U.S.: Winter storm departing northeast, strong winds in California
Justice Department dismantled Hive ransomware group


Germany faces biggest teacher shortage in 50 years, association says

Electricity from renewable sources on the rise in EU
North Carolina: Construction begins on new tower at Asheville Regional Airport
Second weekly decline in active U.S. oil rigs
Australian consumer watchdog launches crackdown on misleading social media influencers
Globalisation redefined as manufacturing moves closer to home

Trending Now

BioMar sources Benson Hill ingredients to boost sustainability of aquafeed

Once-daily Sotyktu gets positive opinion as treatment for adults with moderate-to-severe plaque psoriasis

Electricity from renewable sources on the rise in EU

North Carolina: Construction begins on new tower at Asheville Regional Airport


EU extends economic sanctions against Russia by six months

Iraq, France agree on energy, security cooperation
MEP from Hungary: European gas price cap would have negative effect on gas markets
EU launches €100 million Regional Teachers' Initiative for Africa
Governor announces plan to deliver economic relief to New Mexicans
Missouri awards $30 million in funding to help companies find and train workers

Today We Recommend

EU launches €100 million Regional Teachers' Initiative for Africa


Milo's Tea Company to create 103 new jobs in Spartanburg County, South Carolina

SK Battery America to open U.S. IT center, create 200 high-tech jobs in Roswell, Georgia

Chipotle Mexican Grill to hire 15,000 workers


BioMar sources Benson Hill ingredients to boost sustainability of aquafeed

Milo's Tea Company to create 103 new jobs in Spartanburg County, South Carolina
SK Battery America to open U.S. IT center, create 200 high-tech jobs in Roswell, Georgia
Chipotle Mexican Grill to hire 15,000 workers
Duke Energy begins operation of Idaho’s largest solar plant
BT Group to recruit more than 400 apprentices and graduates


Foresters Financial Canada president Henry Auyeung to retire

Dollar Bank names Peter Kubiska new chief marketing officer
Bank of South Carolina CEO Fleetwood S. Hassell to retire
Drest appoints Henri Holm as CFO
VC4A introducing Vincent Hoogduijn as CEO
Introhive appoints Lee Blakemore as CEO


U.S. trade deficit for goods soar 8.8% to $90.3b in December

Uzbekistan's economy grows 5.7 pct in 2022
Irish consumer confidence hit seven month high in January
Bank of Canada hikes rates
Singapore’s core inflation at 5.1 pct in December, averaged 4.1 pct for 2022
EU trade with Russia declined strongly


American Express Q4 income $1.6 billion

Chevron Q4 earnings $6.4 billion
Weyerhaeuser Q4 profit decreases
LG slips to loss in Q4
Santa Cruz County Bank Q4 income $10.0 million
American Airlines Q4 revenues up 39.9%


Micromanaging is the worst enemy of efficiency and teamwork

Niger set to monetize massive gas reserves through Saharan natural gas pipeline
Putting the brakes on EV folly that choked the market
Oil discovery in Kavango Basin may mean huge benefits for Namibians
Cape Town and Dubai battle over Africa's energy future
Is America going to lose its superpower status?


Eurostat releases food price monitoring tool

New Zealand suffers egg supply shortage
Hong Kong suspends import of poultry meat and products from areas in Mexico and Poland
FAO and Japan to help Moldovan rural households overcome multiple crisis effects
African Development Bank to commit $10 billion to make continent world's breadbasket
Defra: Six more sustainable farming standards to replace Basic Payment Scheme


Product images could boost food pantry use

The madness of fast service: I want it now!
How to build a resilient brand
Only 32% of employees believe their pay is fair
Corporate duty waivers limit organic company growth and innovation
Women buy from women, men buy from women and men


EAO issued third fine for Coastal GasLink project

Dutch central bank fines cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase 3.3 mln euros
Bloomberg to pay $5 million for misleading disclosures about its valuation methodologies for fixed income securities
Italy fines Yoox with over 5 million euro for misleading prices and limitations of right of withdrawal
Nexo agrees to pay $45 million in penalties and cease unregistered offering of crypto asset lending product
Virgin Atlantic fined for operating flights in prohibited airspace



IntercityHotel Berlin Airport BER opens

Art After School, the perfect way to spark imagination in your child
The world's biggest food fair in Berlin you don't wanna miss
Largest antiques show comes to small Texas town
Meet and see great artists from across the United States
Address Grand Creek Harbour opens its doors to guests


Honda Pilot TrailSport, fully equipped SUV with great ground clearance

2024 Corvette E-ray, electrified 4WD
Jaguar I-PACE is now more distinctive
2023 Toyota Prius expected this January
2023 Lincoln Corsair, advance features and ActiveGlide
Lamborghini Huracán Sterrato, first super sports car for any terrain


Solios watches, from nature to luxury

Coats of faux fur, but not of faux style
Redifining kitchen space and experience with workstations
Dinning sofas, a soft addition to a modern dinning table
Patchwork carpets, vintage Persian carpets made with unparalleled skill
Real life wallpapers, perfectly executed


Harman Luxury Audio introduces new JBL Classic Series

KEF KC62, audio excellence and design ingenuity
Panasonic announces flagship OLED TV MZ2000
McIntosh MC451, 150 Watt vacuum tube and 300 Watt solid state amplifier
Headonia 2A3, luxury headphone amplifier that comes with gloves
ASUS launches ExpertBook B9 for executives


Ipsen receives CHMP negative opinion for Palovarotene as treatment for fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva in EU

Once-daily Sotyktu gets positive opinion as treatment for adults with moderate-to-severe plaque psoriasis
EMA update on shortages of antibiotics in EU
Researchers develop new urine test that can diagnose cancer
India launches 'world's first' intranasal COVID-19 vaccine
Quibim and European Commission to launch EUCAIM, federated infrastructure for cancer images data in Europe


NASA system predicts small asteroid to pass close by Earth this week

NASA, Pentagon developing nuclear-powered rocket for Mars
Milky Way found to be too big
Earth's inner core rotation paused
Airbus-built JUICE spacecraft set for lift-off to study Jupiter’s icy moons
Ripples in fabric of universe may reveal start of time