POST Online Media Lite Edition


EU Court of Justice: No more derogations for use of bee-toxic neonicotinoids

Christian Fernsby |
The Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU) published a preliminary ruling on questions posed by the Belgian Administrative Court, following a complaint by PAN Europe, Nature & Progrès Belgium and a Belgian beekeeper.

Article continues below

The Court declared that providing derogations for the treatment of seeds with a banned pesticide and their use is not in line with EU law. This ruling puts a stop to almost half the derogations given by Member States to banned pesticides.

Hans Muilerman, a chemical officer at PAN Europe said: "PAN Europe has been fighting this maladministration for many years. This landmark ruling of the EU Court puts an end to 10 years of abuse by Member States, with the blessing of the European Commission. Thanks to our action, the EU environment will become a safer place."

In 2019, Nature & Progrès Belgium, a Belgian individual beekeeper and PAN Europe filed a request for annulment before the Belgian Administrative Court. This followed a derogation given by Belgium to the sugar lobby for the use of bee-toxic neonicotinoid insecticides on sugar beets.

The complainants suggested the Belgian Court to submit questions for a preliminary ruling to the CJEU in order to clarify the limits of the law with regards to derogations.

Marc Fichers, Secretary General of Nature & Progrès Belgium said: "This success will have an EU-wide effect, to protect bees and insects across the EU, as well as citizen's health. Derogations with neonicotinoid-treated seeds are now definitely banned. This ruling is relieving and shows the environment counts more than profits from some sugar and pesticide companies!"

The procedure in the Court of Justice of the EU was joined by the European Commission, France, Greece, Hungary and Finland. Belgium, as well as a Belgian pesticide company (SES Vanderhave) and the Belgian sugar lobby also intervened to protect their interests.

Martin Dermine, executive director of PAN Europe added: "During the procedure, it was very shocking to observe that the European Commission kept protecting the abuses of the system by Member States.

The Commission supported the provision of derogations for supposedly EU-banned pesticides that are highly toxic to human health and the environment. It was evident that the Commission stood on the side of agribusiness, rather than with citizens' health and the environment!

The European Commission's lawyers even told the judges that Member States only give a derogation when no alternative exists, which is opposite to the reality!"

PAN Europe recently published a report on derogations provided by Member States to EU-banned pesticide substances: 236 such derogations were granted over the last 4 years. Neonicotinoids represent nearly half of those (47.5%).

The report highlights how Member States fail to assess the necessity for such derogations and their compliance with EU law, favouring agribusiness over the protection of citizens' health and the environment.

Pr. Antoine Bailleux, the NGO's lawyer further commented: "This ruling is a huge step forward for the preservation of biodiversity in Europe. The Court of justice has made it clear that substances prohibited at EU level for health or environmental reasons cannot be introduced through the back door at Member State level, which had become common practice.

"It has also confirmed that the protection of health and the environment overrides the objective of improving plant production."

Martin Dermine concluded: "Today is a great day for European pollinators and for our environment. The EU pesticide law gives priority to citizens' health and the environment but its implementation at EU- and national levels is poor.

"This verdict is a reminder that administrations and politicians are bound to the law, not to the interests of the pesticide industry, or industrial agricultural lobbies."

Neonicotinoid insecticides were approved in the EU in the 90's. After 20 years of harm on EU insect populations, the European Commission and Member States partly restricted their use in 2013, to crops that are not attractive to pollinators.

A series of EU Member States immediately issued derogations to keep using them despite of the ban. In 2018, following the ban on all outdoor uses, the number of derogations even increased significantly.

What to read next

Honeybees are struggling to get enough good bacteria
Number of bee species in Michigan exceeded earlier estimates
Bee buzzes could help determine how to save their decreasing population

World's population to decline

Population growth could grind to a halt by 2050, before decreasing to as little as 6 billion humans on Earth in 2100, a new analysis of birth trends has revealed.


Largest investment for housing efforts in Florida
EMA recommends approval of Bimervax as COVID-19 booster vaccine
New Zealand: Catch limits cuts for Northland rock lobster
Serbia: EIB Vice-President Pavlova signs second EU grant for Belgrade – Niš railway


U.S.: Severe thunderstorms forecast for portions of Plains, Mississippi Valley, and mid south

Mayor Scott’s statement on Clean Harbors’ decision to not process East Palestine, Oh. wastewater in Baltimore
German public sector wage talks fail, enter truce phase
Bulgarian farmers protest duty-free grain imports from Ukraine
Denmark says object found at Nord Stream 2 pipeline probably empty smoke buoy
At least 31 dead after Philippines ferry carrying 250 passengers catches fire


Mayor Wu to expand Boston's tuition free community college program

£21bn of public money lost in fraud since COVID pandemic, most forever
Electricity Consumers Society of Kenya seeks order quashing increment in power tariffs
Greece raises $2.7 billion
Vitamins market estimated to reach $8.9 billion
New cars sold in EU must be zero-emission from 2035

Trending Now

Alfa Romeo Tonale Edizione Bambini, perfect for family

Mayor Scott’s statement on Clean Harbors’ decision to not process East Palestine, Oh. wastewater in Baltimore

Mayor Wu to expand Boston's tuition free community college program

U.S.: Severe thunderstorms forecast for portions of Plains, Mississippi Valley, and mid south


Georgia lawmakers agree to pay full tuition for college scholarships

New York: Start of construction on $67 million public housing development in Troy
Serbia: Great importance of traffic connection with Hungary
German government introduces draft law to attract foreign skilled workers
Türkiye pledges to supply natural gas to Hungary
Belgium to support Kenya's transformation agenda

Today We Recommend

Vitamins market estimated to reach $8.9 billion


Petrofac, Hitachi Energy receive 13 billion euros agreement from TenneT

Lululemon Athletica Q4 revenue increased

Origin Energy agrees to $10.21 billion takeover deal from Brookfield consortium


Italy: Terna, EIB provides second and third tranches of €1.9 billion loan for Tyrrhenian Link

Dr. Oetker to acquire frozen pizza snacks company Galileo Lebensmittel
Primark giving 26,000 shop workers pay rise from April
Petrofac, Hitachi Energy receive 13 billion euros agreement from TenneT
DP World opens one-stop refrigerated container facility in Sydney
Vale to pay $55.9 million to settle charges related to misleading disclosures prior to deadly dam collapse


SEACOM announces new group CEO

Appian appoints Douglas Coleman as head of Mexico
DTiQ announces senior leadership appointment
Vanda Pharmaceuticals appoints Tage Honoré to board
Akhona Qengqe to become KFC Africa’s new general manager
Marlabs appoints Usha Jamadagni as chief delivery officer


U.S. consumer confidence unexpectedly improves in March

Italy: Consumer confidence strengthens in March
Scotland's onshore GDP increased by 0.9% in January
Italy’s foreign trade with non-EU27 countries increased
U.S. trade deficit for goods rises 0.6% to $91.6 billion in February
Virginia labor force participation nears pre-pandemic level


H&M Q1 profit rises

Lululemon Athletica Q4 revenue increased
Cal-Maine Foods Q3 sales $997.5 million
Jefferies Q1 earnings $134 million
Dollarama Q4 sales increased
Dollarama Q4 sales increased


Micromanaging is the worst enemy of efficiency and teamwork

Niger set to monetize massive gas reserves through Saharan natural gas pipeline
Putting the brakes on EV folly that choked the market
Oil discovery in Kavango Basin may mean huge benefits for Namibians
Cape Town and Dubai battle over Africa's energy future
Is America going to lose its superpower status?


Ireland: Minister Hackett announces commencement of Organic Farming Scheme 2022 balancing payments

Namibia suspends poultry imports from Argentina, Chile after bird flu outbreaks
Michigan: HPAI detected in Lapeer County flock
Russia's Volgograd region: Batch of celery infected with quarantine harmful objects arrived from Iran
Hong Kong suspends import of poultry meat and products from areas in Argentina, Japan
Emergency support allows families in Moldova to feed their cattle


Acquisitions can nix existing partnerships

Success of working from home depends on company health
Consumers less likely to support brands with unconventional spellings
HR practices have both positive and negative effects on employee mental health
CEO education is no guarantee of stock market success
How remote work affects managers


Former CFO of Russian natural gas company Novatek convicted of making false statements to IRS

William Hill almost lost licence, fined record $24 million for gambling failures
UK construction firms fined nearly £60 million for breaking competition law by bid rigging
Former Puerto Rico mayor convicted of accepting bribes
McDonald's fined $53,000 in South Korea for leaking customers data
Poland: UOKIK fines Merida Polska $573,000



To taste good maple taffy come to Maple Sugar Festival

Watches and Wonders trade fair kicks off in Geneva
Arkansas Times Craft Beer Festival is back and better than ever
laïla, Seychelles opens
Five day street food festival in Mangaluru brings Indian food to city
Qatar International Food Festival is back


Alfa Romeo Tonale Edizione Bambini, perfect for family

Dodge Challenger SRT Demon 170, 1,025 HP for your joy
First GMC Sierra EV, power source on wheels
Ford Puma ST Powershift, most powerful 1.0‑litre EcoBoost engine
Toyota launches new Prius PHEV in Japan
Ariel Atom, serious motor sport or ultimate fun


Italian coffee makers to feel like a pro

Juliska tableware, collections for every occasion
Wool coats, a timeless fashion investment
Venetto bedding, creating a beautiful bedroom space
Bed headboards, sleep like a king
Great rugs for generations responsibly made


Focal Vestia N°3, floorstanding loudspeaker for accomplished performance

New Cherry microphones for professional sound quality
Mobile Fidelity UltraDeck turntable, extreme pursuit of highest level of reproduction
Nokia G22, good smartphone you can fix yourself
NAD C 3050 LE amplifier, a classic reinvented
Asus Zenbook S 13 OLED, ultralighta and powerful laptop with OLED display


China plans random, spot checks at hospitals to track COVID

FDA approves first over the counter naloxone nasal spray
British Columbia takes actions to prevent shortage of diabetes drug
Oklahoma women now have access to expanded pregnancy and postpartum coverage
Luxembourg makes contraception free in April
Legal cannabis markets linked to increased motor vehicle deaths


Supermassive black hole 30 billion times the mass of our Sun discovered

China’s Chang’e-5 lander finds potential water reservoir on moon
Park Board: Help keep Vancouver’s Canada goose population in check
Large asteroid coming close
Kenya on high alert after Tanzania reports Marburg disease outbreak
New findings released from world's most powerful solar telescope