Netherlands may exempt kosher slaughterhouse from export ban
Caspar Itz, a spokesman for the Ministry of Economic Affairs, was replying to JTA’s questions following the publication of a letter written by the lawyer for the Slagerij Marcus abattoir saying the slaughterhouse would not survive the implementation of a government policy paper limiting the production of meat without stunning to the needs of faith communities in the Netherlands.
“Upon request, special circumstances may be taken into account” when it comes to the de facto ban in export, Itz wrote in an email. His letter did not say whether such an exception would apply to the Jewish-owned abattoir specifically.
The limitation on the export of kosher and halal meat came in an agreement signed by Economic Affairs Minister Martijn van Dam and Muslim and Jewish faith and community leaders, including from the Organization of Jewish Communities in the Netherlands, or NIK.
The extension of a 2012 agreement on the production of kosher and halal meat introduced a new stipulation on export.
A clause in the document signed July 5 states that meat may be produced without stunning the animals, as is common in kosher slaughter, but that such meat will “not exceed the actual needs of communities present in the Netherlands.”
The slaughterhouse’s lawyer, Herman Loonstein, wrote to NIK that this stipulation means bankruptcy for Slagerij Marcus, which relies on export for approximately 40 percent of its revenue.
Religious laws in Islam and Judaism require animals be conscious when their necks are cut.
Animal rights activist consider this practice cruel, though its advocates argue it results in less or equal suffering compared to industrial slaughter methods with stunning.
Nationalists and anti-Islam activists also oppose ritual slaughter in Europe, ostensibly because they view it as foreign to their native culture. ■