POST Online Media Lite Edition


Nestlé and Mondelez in fight over Kit Kat 4 fingers

Staff Writer |
In 2002, Nestlé applied to EUIPO (European Union Intellectual Property Office) for registration as an EU trade mark of the three-dimensional mark, which corresponds to the product "Kit Kat 4 fingers."

Article continues below

In 2006, EUIPO agreed to register that mark in respect of the following goods: "Sweets, bakery products, pastries, biscuits, cakes, waffles." In 2007, Cadbury Schweppes (now Mondelez UK Holdings & Services) applied to EUIPO for a declaration of invalidity.

In 2012, EUIPO dismissed that application, considering that Nestlé’s mark had acquired distinctive character through the use that had been made of it within the EU. Mondelez claims that the General Court should annul EUIPO’s decision.

By new judgment, the General Court annuls EUIPO’s decision. First of all, the Court recalls that, if a trade mark has been registered for a category of goods containing several sub-categories, proof that the mark has been put to genuine use in relation to a part of those goods affords protection only for the corresponding sub-category or sub-categories.

The Court holds that none of the evidence taken into consideration by EUIPO establishes use of the mark in respect of bakery products, pastries, cakes and waffles. Consequently, EUIPO erred in law in considering that the product in question could be included in any of the categories of goods concerned.

Next, the Court recalls that a three-dimensional mark may acquire distinctive character through use, even if it is used in conjunction with a word mark or a figurative mark, and in order for distinctive character to be acquired through use, the sign applied for must have come to identify the product concerned as originating from a particular undertaking.

The Court then examines the evidence taken into account by EUIPO, such as the market surveys carried out in 10 Member States, the advertising material, and how long-standing the use of the mark has been.

It confirms that that evidence is capable of establishing that, in the eyes of the relevant public, the three-dimensional mark in question is perceived as an indication of the commercial origin of the goods concerned.

As regards Mondelez’s assertion that Nestlé has not proved distinctive character acquired through use of its mark throughout the EU, the Court considers that distinctive character acquired through use of a mark must be demonstrated in the part of the EU where it was devoid of intrinsic distinctive character, namely in the present case, throughout the EU at the date of filing the application for registration on 21 March 2002 (at that time, the EU was composed of 15 Member States).

In that regard, it is not sufficient to show that a significant proportion of the relevant public throughout the EU, merging all the Member States and regions, perceives a mark as an indication of the commercial origin of the goods designated by the mark.

In the case of a mark which, like Nestlé’s mark, does not have inherent distinctive character throughout the EU, the distinctive character acquired through use of that mark must be shown in all the Member States concerned.

Although it had been established that the contested trade mark had acquired distinctive character through use in 10 countries (Denmark, Germany, Spain, France, Italy, the Netherlands, Austria, Finland, Sweden and the UK), the Court considers that EUIPO could not validly conclude its examination without coming to a conclusion regarding the perception of the mark by the relevant public in, inter alia, Belgium, Ireland, Greece and Portugal and without analysing the evidence adduced in respect of those Member States.

The Court concludes that EUIPO erred in considering that it was not necessary to prove distinctive character acquired through use of a mark in all the Member States concerned.

It follows that EUIPO will have to take another decision in which it verifies that, at the date of filing the application for registration, the mark in question had acquired distinctive character through the use that Nestlé had made of it in the 15 Member States concerned in respect of "sweets and biscuits."

What to read next

Nestlé reorganizes infant nutrition business
Nestlé USA to relocate headquarters to Arlington County, Va.
Mondelez sells most of grocery business in Oceania for $345.3 million

Caterpillar Q4 profit decreases

Caterpillar revealed earnings for fourth quarter that decreased from last year.


Novartis Q4 income declined 91 percent
GSK Q4 profit climbs
UK ready to boost CPTPP’s economic clout, says Trade Minister on Asia-Pacific visit
Commission approves €1.6 billion Romania measure to capitalise new investment and development bank


Fire put out at South Korea's space centre during test for next generation space rocket

Submarine volcano erupts in Vanuatu
UK faces fresh mass strikes
Reported death toll due to bad weather 44 in Philippines
After 1,400km long search missing radioactive capsule from Rio Tinto found in Australia
U.S.: Dangerous ice storm for portions of south


Mayor Lightfoot celebrates completion of Terminal 5 at O’hare International Airport

Sustainable Energy Fund for Africa grant to drive electric mobility shift in 7 African countries
Battery-only electric passenger cars: +76% in Europe in 2021
UK drivers warned to keep eye on pump prices
Biden presents work on Baltimore tunnel, 72,000 new jobs expected
2022 Corruption Perceptions Index: Corruption levels remain at standstill

Trending Now

South Africa authorises roll out of COVID-19 boosters to fight Omicron variant

After 1,400km long search missing radioactive capsule from Rio Tinto found in Australia

Battery-only electric passenger cars: +76% in Europe in 2021

GM and Lithium Americas to develop U.S. lithium production through $650 million deal


UK Government backing helps launch world first self-driving bus

Commission approves €104 million Croatian scheme to support energy-intensive companies
Canada invests in BHP project to develop world-leading low-emissions potash mine
New York: Over $22 million awarded in Round XII of Regional Economic Development Council Initiative
Russia, China draft agreement on construction, operation of gas pipeline across Ussuri River
Azerbaijan, Hungary sign memorandum of cooperation in gas sector

Today We Recommend

Biofertilizers market to surpass $5.71 billion


Novartis Q4 income declined 91 percent

GM and Lithium Americas to develop U.S. lithium production through $650 million deal

Biden presents work on Baltimore tunnel, 72,000 new jobs expected


HVS awarded share of £6.6m government funding to develop world’s first self-driving hydrogen HGV

GM and Lithium Americas to develop U.S. lithium production through $650 million deal
Dole announces sale of its fresh vegetables division to Chiquita subsidiary Fresh Express
ExxonMobil awards FEED for world’s largest low-carbon hydrogen facility
Metronet begins construction of Daytona’s multi-gigabit 100 percent fiber optic network, will hire
Boeing to deliver last 747


Exothera appoints Darren Leva as chief business officer

Vesta taps Shimon Steinmetz as CFO
Bruno Ultra Barcelos appointed managing director of Ethypharm UK
Syntach names Patrick NJ Schnegelsberg as new CEO
Chiesi appoints Giuseppe Accogli as new group CEO
Foresters Financial Canada president Henry Auyeung to retire


Italian economic growth stronger than expected in 2022

UK shop prices record high, peak still to come
GDP up by 0.1% in euro area and stable in EU
Portuguese economy sees fastest growth for 35 years in 2022
Canada's real GDP edged up 0.1% in November
Hungary: Economic sentiment ticks up in January


Phillips 66 Q4 earnings $1.9 billion

McDonald's Q4 profit increases
Pfizer Q4 profit increases
General Motors Q4 profit up
Exxon Mobil Q4 earnings $12.8 billion
UBS Q4 profit rises


Micromanaging is the worst enemy of efficiency and teamwork

Niger set to monetize massive gas reserves through Saharan natural gas pipeline
Putting the brakes on EV folly that choked the market
Oil discovery in Kavango Basin may mean huge benefits for Namibians
Cape Town and Dubai battle over Africa's energy future
Is America going to lose its superpower status?


Ukraine opens Canadian, Serbian markets for export of livestock products since year beginning

Egypt intends to buy more wheat from Russia, working on system to pay in rubles
Rosselkhoznadzor stopped shipment of infected oats from Irkutsk to Mongolia
Philippines: ORION Program targets to perk up onion industry, increase domestic supply
Belarus lifts restrictions on food exports to neighboring EU countries
Argentina added new market: Algeria enabled export of meat with bone


Lucky CEO means bad luck for hiring company

Product images could boost food pantry use
The madness of fast service: I want it now!
How to build a resilient brand
Only 32% of employees believe their pay is fair
Corporate duty waivers limit organic company growth and innovation


AG for District of Colubia: $1,950,000 available for eligible Drizly drivers as result of tip-theft investigation

North Carolina: 52 stores pay fines for price scanning errors in 33 counties
EAO issued third fine for Coastal GasLink project
Dutch central bank fines cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase 3.3 mln euros
Bloomberg to pay $5 million for misleading disclosures about its valuation methodologies for fixed income securities
Italy fines Yoox with over 5 million euro for misleading prices and limitations of right of withdrawal



La Chandeleur in Paris: Crêpe Day for all of you

Tru by Hilton Monterrey Fundidora hotel opens in Mexico
IntercityHotel Berlin Airport BER opens
Art After School, the perfect way to spark imagination in your child
The world's biggest food fair in Berlin you don't wanna miss
Largest antiques show comes to small Texas town


Honda Pilot TrailSport, fully equipped SUV with great ground clearance

2024 Corvette E-ray, electrified 4WD
Jaguar I-PACE is now more distinctive
2023 Toyota Prius expected this January
2023 Lincoln Corsair, advance features and ActiveGlide
Lamborghini Huracán Sterrato, first super sports car for any terrain


Curved sofas, elegant and gentle

Solios watches, from nature to luxury
Coats of faux fur, but not of faux style
Redifining kitchen space and experience with workstations
Dinning sofas, a soft addition to a modern dinning table
Patchwork carpets, vintage Persian carpets made with unparalleled skill


Harman Luxury Audio introduces new JBL Classic Series

KEF KC62, audio excellence and design ingenuity
Panasonic announces flagship OLED TV MZ2000
McIntosh MC451, 150 Watt vacuum tube and 300 Watt solid state amplifier
Headonia 2A3, luxury headphone amplifier that comes with gloves
ASUS launches ExpertBook B9 for executives


South Africa authorises roll out of COVID-19 boosters to fight Omicron variant

FDA approves Orserdutm for patients with advanced or metastatic breast cancer
Indonesia to start rolling out COVID-19 vaccination for children under 6
Ipsen receives CHMP negative opinion for Palovarotene as treatment for fibrodysplasia ossificans progressiva in EU
Once-daily Sotyktu gets positive opinion as treatment for adults with moderate-to-severe plaque psoriasis
EMA update on shortages of antibiotics in EU


Green comet to visit Earth after 50,000 years

Astronomers captured spectacular, ongoing collision between at least three galaxy clusters
NASA system predicts small asteroid to pass close by Earth this week
NASA, Pentagon developing nuclear-powered rocket for Mars
Milky Way found to be too big
Earth's inner core rotation paused