POST Online Media Lite Edition


South Africa: Commission conditionally approves Kwande Capital and Nampak transaction

Christian Fernsby |
The Commission has approved with conditions the proposed transaction in which Kwande Capital through Isanti Glass 1 intends to acquire the glass packaging business and plant Nampak Glass, a division of Nampak Products.

Article continues below


Isanti is a special purpose vehicle (SPV) formed for the purpose of the proposed transaction. Isanti is controlled by Kwande. The remaining minority shareholding is held by SABSA Holdings (Pty) Ltd (SABSA) a subsidiary of Anheuser-Busch InBev SA/NV group (AB InBev).

As part of the transaction AB InBev will provide technical support to Nampak Glass to assist it to improve its operational efficiency.

Nampak Glass is a division of Nampak Products. Nampak Products is a wholly owned subsidiary of Nampak Limited. Nampak Limited is a public company incorporated in South Africa.

The target business does not directly or indirectly control any firm.

The Commission found that there is no competitive overlap (horizontal overlap) between the activities of Isanti and Nampak Glass.

However, due to SABSA’s stake in Isanti, the proposed transaction results in a customer-supplier (vertical) overlap in relation to the (i) upstream market for the manufacture and supply of glass containers (upstream market)and (ii) the downstream market for the production and supply of alcoholic beverages, particularly beer and flavoured alcoholic beverages (FABs) (the downstream market).

The upstream market is highly concentrated with only two players, namely Nampak Glass and Consol Glass (Pty) Ltd (Consol). Consol is a dominant firm in the upstream market, with a market share upwards of 70% based on both output and sales value. Nampak Glass accounts for the rest.

The downstream market for the sale of clear beer is also highly concentrated with AB InBev accounting for market shares upwards of 75% based on sales volumes and sales value.

Heineken is the second largest player in this market. In the market for FABs, Distell has the highest market share and AB InBev is the second largest player. Pre-merger, AB InBev procured a large proportion of its glass packaging requirements from Consol.

Post-merger, AB InBev intends switching the bulk of its glass packaging input requirements from Consol to Nampak, essentially following a strategy of self-supply.

This raises input foreclosure concerns for other downstream users of glass containers, as Nampak would no longer be able to supply third party users at pre-merger levels.

In addition to the foreclosure concerns mentioned above, the Commission was also concerned that the transaction may raise unilateral price effects.

In this regard, the Commission notes that Nampak is an important rival to a dominant firm and a valuable alternative supplier to third parties to ensure security of supply. Nampak also provided competitive prices to customers.

If a large proportion of Nampak’s output is provided to SABSA post-merger, third parties may lose these benefits.

The Commission is also concerned that the proposed transaction may raise information exchange concerns through AB InBev’s involvement as technical partner in Nampak Glass postmerger.

The merging parties have submitted that Nampak Glass is currently experiencing operational difficulties.

The Commission assessed this and concluded that the continued operation of Nampak Glass as an effective competitor, absent the proposed transaction, is unlikely and that Nampak would benefit from technical efficiency improvements brought by AB InBev’s involvement as a technical partner through the merger.

Regarding public interest considerations, the Commission found that the transaction is likely to introduce the first black owned glass manufacturer in South Africa.

The merging parties have also committed to ensuring that there is no adverse effect on historically disadvantaged recycled glass collectors.

Whilst the merging parties dispute that the proposed transaction results in competition and public interest concerns, they have nonetheless tendered remedies to address the concerns raised by the Commission and by third parties.

These include remedies in relation to employment, effects on the glass recycling sector, supply to third party customers post-merger, investment in additional capacity, and proposals to limit anticompetitive information exchange.

The Commission is of the view that these remedies may, on balance, address the concerns resulting from the proposed transaction.

With respect to third party supply, the merging parties commit to making a material proportion of their planned output available to third parties, on commercially reasonable terms, for 4 years.

The merging parties have also committed to comply with the terms and conditions of any pre-existing customer supply agreements that are in place at the time of the merger.

The merging parties further commit to taking all steps within their auspices to add additional glass manufacturing capacity within the medium term.

Further, in the event that there are production stoppages or shortages, Nampak Glass will ensure that output is allocated in a non-discriminatory manner.

To safeguard against any potential sharing of competitively sensitive information, the merging parties will, amongst other safeguards, implement an information exchange policy.

Further, the merging parties are required not to retrench any employees as a result of the merger and to ensure that they procure recycled glass for use in their operations in the ordinary course.

While the Commission is cognisant that post-merger, third party customers will be in a difficult position in relation to their ability to access capacity at the merged entity and at Consol, the Commission does, however, note that, pre-merger, customers were already operating in a market facing capacity constraints.

The merger does not resolve the capacity constraints, but by maintaining Nampak’s production capacity in the market, the merger ensures that the constraints are not worsened.

The Commission thus notes that on the balance of probabilities, a conditional approval of this transaction presents better competitive outcomes for the market.

What to read next

South Africa approves SABMiller, Coke deal with conditions
EC clears ArcelorMittal's acquisition of Ilva, subject to conditions
P&G OKs $12.5 billion offer to merge 43 P&G Beauty Brands with Coty

Sonic Automotive acquires Audi Owings Mills in Maryland

Sonic Automotive announced it has acquired Audi Owings Mills.


Ponsse launches new technology: electric forest machine
First 100 Ukrainian farmers compensated through WFCU agricultural loan reimbursement program
Radisson Resort Plaza Skiathos opens in Greece
Mainstream Renewable Power pledges to create 100 new jobs in Ireland


Malaysia's passenger flight denied landing at Myanmar's Yangon Airport

American naval training aircraft crashes in Texas
Plane with damaged wing makes emergency landing in Irkutsk region
U.S.: Excessive heat for south and west, flash flooding conditions in southwest
Iran seizes unprecedented amount of crystal meth
South Africa: Police operations net 53 suspected illegal miners


Norway's July gas exports hit record high

Nearly 70% of America's top executives affiliated with Republicans
Russian gas supplies via Ukraine, Nord Stream to remain at previous volumes on Wednesday
EU economy greenhouse gases still below pre-COVID levels
Hundreds of workers at Liverpool port vote to strike over pay
Five more grain-carrying ships leave Ukrainian ports

Trending Now

Sonic Automotive acquires Audi Owings Mills in Maryland

First 100 Ukrainian farmers compensated through WFCU agricultural loan reimbursement program

Ponsse launches new technology: electric forest machine

Russian gas supplies via Ukraine, Nord Stream to remain at previous volumes on Wednesday


President Biden signs climate, health care package

Czech Republic seizes part of Gazprom’s gas storage capacity
Minister Ng to strengthen Canada-Philippines ties with upcoming visit
New trading scheme in UK cuts tariffs on hundreds of everyday products
Hungarian government to fast-track domestic gas production
Illinois Governor announces $34.6 billion investment in transportation over six years

Today We Recommend

Nearly 70% of America's top executives affiliated with Republicans


Mainstream Renewable Power pledges to create 100 new jobs in Ireland

Navitas Semiconductor acquires GeneSiC Semiconductor for $100 million

Shoprite acquires 100 new fuel-efficient Scania Euro V trucks


Next.e.GO Mobile starts building €720mn electronic car plant in North Macedonia

EIB to support Ryvu Therapeutics with €22 million
Gazprom does not rule out gas prices in Europe over $4,000 in winter
Joysbio developed two new monkeypox tests that deliver results in 15 minutes
Chester company supplying Airbus and Magellan Aerospace faces strikes
Navitas Semiconductor acquires GeneSiC Semiconductor for $100 million


Louisiana: Vernon Parish man arrested for timber theft

Philips appoints Roy Jakobs as president and CEO
Daseke appoints Bruce Blaise to board
Island Pacific appoints Herman Chiu as CFO
Horizon Bancorp appoints Thomas M. Prame as president
Encora appoints Deepak Bhandari as EVP, head of corporate development


Russian Economy Ministry expects inflation to reach 13.4% in 2022, GDP to drop to 4.2%

Indonesia sets economic growth at 5.3 percent, inflation at 3.3 percent in 2023
Slovenia's Q2 GDP growth slows to 8.2 pct y-o-y
UK inflation hits 10.1% in 40-year high
U.S. housing market index drops to two-year low in August
German investor confidence falls


Walmart Q2 profit advances

Home Depot Q2 profit climbs
BioMar achieves record Q2
AD Ports Group Q2 net profit surges 59%
Strauss Group H1 revenue increased 8%
BHP net profit nearly triples


Micromanaging is the worst enemy of efficiency and teamwork

Niger set to monetize massive gas reserves through Saharan natural gas pipeline
Putting the brakes on EV folly that choked the market
Oil discovery in Kavango Basin may mean huge benefits for Namibians
Cape Town and Dubai battle over Africa's energy future
Is America going to lose its superpower status?


Commission approves €218 million Bulgarian scheme to support agricultural producers

HPAI case in Pennsylvania affects Warren County in New Jersey
South Africa suspends cattle movement to control foot and mouth disease
Russia sent first batches of fodder meal from Kursk region to Vietnam
Rosselkhoznadzor: Illegal import of more than 500,000 doses of vaccine against low pathogenic avian infections stopped
Philippines finds $643,765 worth of smuggled onions from China


51% of supply chain leaders increased number of network locations

If company overcomes post-IPO innovation slump, it will survive longer
62% of consumers will stop buying from brands that compromise products to cut costs
Companies must invest to avoid supply chain scandal or pay the price in lost consumers
How awards, recognition decrease inventors' creativity
Keeping employees is harder than ever. And we don't have good news


Massachusetts AG reaches settlement with opioid maker Endo

Google LLC to pay $60 million for collecting users' location data
Ex-company director from Solihull to pay £11,200 for exporting banned waste
South Korea fines 11 companies $197.5 million for price fixing
Healthcare workers in Italy put at risk due to aggravated fraud relating to protective face masks and suits
South Africa's Special Tribunal orders freeze of Transnet executives' assets



Dublin Horse Show 2022, a packed programme of races, food and drink

Enjoy the best Greek food in Alaska
The SureStay Hotel by Best Western Rockford East opens in Rockford, Illinois
Avani Chaweng Samui Hotel & Beach Club opens in Thailand
Buffalo Bill is coming to Manitowoc with his Wild West show
Pullman Doha West Bay Hotel opens in Qatar


New Ford Maverick Tremor Off-Road Package revealed

Porsche unveils newest generation of 911 GT3 R
2023 Subaru Crosstrek sells like hotcakes
New Mercedes‑Benz GLC, at home on any terrain
GMC unleashes new 2023 Sierra 1500 AT4X AEV Edition
First BMW M3 Touring presented


Clean and luxurious men's watches

Nobody's Child, everybody's favorite
Freddy WR.UP, pants that hug you in all the right places
Stylishly luxurious house design
Great design ideas that might not work for you
Garden mirrors, explore new views of your garden


Pro-Ject X8 turntable, superior noise suppression and great sound

Shure MV7 professional dynamic microphone now available in new limited-edition color
Forget streaming services, use McIntosh MR89 to enjoy AM/FM music
Infinix NOTE 12 PRO, first smartphone powered by MediaTek Helio G99
MW75 active noise-cancelling headphones, variety of new features
Parasound JC 1+ mono power amplifier by John Curl, pure delight


FDA to allow sale of hearing aids over the counter

West Nile virus kills 1 in Serbia
Infected blood victims in UK to receive £100,000 interim compensation payment
Malta receives first shipment of monkeypox vaccine
Iran reports first monkeypox case
Uruguay decreed universal and free care for hyperacute stroke treatment


Black hole ready for its close-up

Earth's water may be from asteroids
Climate change increasing risk of megaflood in California, Americans ill-prepared and uninsured
Brightest stars in the night sky can strip Neptune-sized planets to their rocky cores
California weather is trending toward extremes
Swiss mountain pass ice to melt completely within weeks