POST Online Media Lite Edition



 

Tronox to vigorously fight FTC lawsuit against Cristal acquisition

Staff Writer |
Tronox Limited said it would vigorously fight a lawsuit by the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) seeking to block the company's proposed acquisition of the titanium dioxide (TiO2) business of Cristal.

Article continues below






Cristal is a privately held global chemical and mining company headquartered in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia.

Tronox maintains that the FTC's complaint is based on an erroneous view of the global TiO2 market and a flawed analysis of the Tronox/Cristal transaction.

"It is extremely disappointing that the FTC has taken this unmerited action to try to block a highly synergistic acquisition which will enhance competition in the TiO2 industry and benefit our customers around the world," said Tronox chief executive officer Jeffry N. Quinn.

"Our combination with Cristal is an important part of our strategy to build a vertically integrated company that will deliver a low-cost, secure supply of TiO2 pigment to a global customer base."

In brief, the company maintains that the FTC has made significant errors in its analysis of the transaction, including:

The FTC's case is premised on a narrow and flawed view of the size of the TiO2 market.

The commission, for example, focuses on TiO2 produced by the chloride process, all but ignoring TiO2 produced via the sulfate process, thereby overlooking nearly half of the available product and miscalculating the market share of individual producers, including overstating the post-transaction Tronox/Cristal.

Similarly, the commission's proposed North American market ignores global trade flows and excludes a significant amount of TiO2 imported from Europe and Asia.

The FTC has taken the position that the market operates as an oligopoly, and the post-merger Tronox/Cristal will coordinate to restrain production. In fact, the combined company will have powerful incentives to run its pigment plants at full capacity, regardless of the activities of competitors.

The FTC believes the merger partners intend to cut pigment production unilaterally. The opposite is true — the transaction makes sense only if the combined firm can exploit all potential synergies to safely expand production at a lower cost per ton.

Tronox first filed its Hart-Scott-Rodino notification form on March 14, 2017. The waiting period has been extended several times by agreement of the parties, including after the company had fully complied with the FTC's Second Request.

During such time, Tronox fully and completely cooperated with the FTC, diligently responding to all questions and information requests, including producing over one million pages of documents for its review

In its press release earlier today, the FTC attempted to refute Tronox's prior public announcement that the waiting period in the United States under the Hart-Scott-Rodino Act expired at 11:59 p.m. EST on December 1, 2017 by suggesting that the FTC and Tronox are parties to a written agreement not to close the transaction until Tronox provided FTC staff with 10 business days' advance notice.

In fact, on October 25, 2017 (26 business days prior to December 1), Tronox provided the FTC with an unambiguous notice of its intent to close the transaction at the end of the statutory waiting period (which was extended to December 1 by agreement of Tronox and Cristal), assuming all other conditions to closing were satisfied as of that date.


What to read next

Tronox to buy Alkali Chemicals for $1.64 billion
After years of investigations California sues Morgan Stanley
BlackBerry files suit against Typo

U.S.: Monsoon continues in the west, locally heavy rain along Gulf Coast

 
Monsoonal moisture and upper-level impulses will aid in producing diurnal showers and thunderstorms with heavy rain from the Northern/Central Rockies to the Southwest/Southeastern California through Sunday.
 
 

Latest

Fifth caravan of grain ships departs from Ukraine
U.S. oil, gas rig count falls for second week in a row
Drought declared in several parts of England
Ex-company director from Solihull to pay £11,200 for exporting banned waste

NEWS

Free vaccinations, testing, oral health exams for kids, other healthcare services available at Illinois State Fair

South Korea president pardons convicted Samsung and Lotte leaders 'to help economy'
Indonesia intensifies search for largest corruption suspect in history
Italy reports 31,703 COVID-19 cases, 145 deaths in 24 hours
City donates 500 decommissioned computers to be refurbished and provided to Detroit families
South Korea's old fighter jet crashes during security mission
 

BUSINESS

Six Gulf of Mexico oil platforms shut due to pipeline leakage

First hydrogen bunkering license issued in Netherlands
Flooring market size worth $635.12 billion by 2030
First Ukraine grain deal vessel docks in Türkiye after buyer refuses delivery
West Virgina Governor declares State of Emergency to address jail staffing shortages
FCC: SpaceX's $1 billion rural network doesn't work
 

Trending Now

Ex-company director from Solihull to pay £11,200 for exporting banned waste

Governor Ron DeSantis encourages veterans to apply for temporary teaching certificates

South Korea president pardons convicted Samsung and Lotte leaders 'to help economy'

First hydrogen bunkering license issued in Netherlands


POLITICS

South Dakota Governor, colleagues ask President Biden to lift vaccine mandate on international travel

Governor Ron DeSantis encourages veterans to apply for temporary teaching certificates
Commission approves modifications to an existing Polish scheme to support companies
Wisconsin Governor Evers, Minnesota Governor Walz seek federal funds for major Duluth-superior bridge project
Rhode Island Governor announces plan for direct rate relief to low-income customers electricity bills
Lukashenko: Belarus should make maximum use of Russian ports
 

Today We Recommend

Flooring market size worth $635.12 billion by 2030


Highlights 

Abbott to create 1,000 new jobs in Kilkenny and Donegal, Ireland

WebstaurantStore expands operations in Georgia, creates 213 new jobs in Bryan County

88 Energy found 1.03 billion barrels of oil


COMPANIES

CATL announced its second European battery plant in Hungary

Johnson & Johnson to sell controversial talc-based baby powder for another year
Abbott to create 1,000 new jobs in Kilkenny and Donegal, Ireland
Port of Tallinn closes operations in Paljassaare harbour
LP Building Solutions announces 50 new jobs in Sagola Township, Michigan
WebstaurantStore expands operations in Georgia, creates 213 new jobs in Bryan County
 

CAREERS

Daseke appoints Bruce Blaise to board

Island Pacific appoints Herman Chiu as CFO
Horizon Bancorp appoints Thomas M. Prame as president
Encora appoints Deepak Bhandari as EVP, head of corporate development
Firmenich: Maurizio Clementi interim president of taste and beyond division
Joyce Farms appoints two new leaders
 

ECONOMY

Slovak industry slowed down, production fell by 5.7% year-on-year in June

Ghana's inflation rises to 31.7 percent in July
Georgia shatters investment and job records in FY22
Cyprus imports of goods €1.152,8 mn
Singapore GDP growth narrowed 3.0 to 4.0 percent
Inflation in Portugal rises to 30 year high
 

EARNINGS

Illumina Q2 revenue up 3%

Canada Goose Q1 2023 revenue grew 24.2%
RWE adjusted EBITDA grows, will invest €5 billion in green strategy
METRO Q3 sales increased by 27.2%
Hapag-Lloyd H1 EBITDA $10.9 billion
ThyssenKrupp Q3 sales improved by 26 percent
 

OP-ED

Micromanaging is the worst enemy of efficiency and teamwork

Niger set to monetize massive gas reserves through Saharan natural gas pipeline
Putting the brakes on EV folly that choked the market
Oil discovery in Kavango Basin may mean huge benefits for Namibians
Cape Town and Dubai battle over Africa's energy future
Is America going to lose its superpower status?
 

AGRIFISH

Food prices in New Zealand increase 7.4 percent annually

Colorado State Veterinarian confirms equine West Nile Virus case in Weld County
Moving cotton harvest equipment into Louisiana is restricted without proper inspection
Spotted lanternfly found in Oakland County, Michigan
Morocco: Cereal campaign 2021/2022, production down 67%
Canada expands market for fresh British Columbia cherries to South Korea
 

LEADERSHIP

If company overcomes post-IPO innovation slump, it will survive longer

62% of consumers will stop buying from brands that compromise products to cut costs
Companies must invest to avoid supply chain scandal or pay the price in lost consumers
How awards, recognition decrease inventors' creativity
Keeping employees is harder than ever. And we don't have good news
How much is 'great resignation' costing companies?
 

CRIME

South Korea fines 11 companies $197.5 million for price fixing

Healthcare workers in Italy put at risk due to aggravated fraud relating to protective face masks and suits
South Africa's Special Tribunal orders freeze of Transnet executives' assets
New York City announces settlement with Chipotle Mexican Grill securing $20m for 13,000 workers
PwC fined $2 million over BT audit after fraud discovered in Italy
Guardia di Financa finds unregistered foreign company operating in e-commerce
 

Magazine

TRAVEL

The SureStay Hotel by Best Western Rockford East opens in Rockford, Illinois

Avani Chaweng Samui Hotel & Beach Club opens in Thailand
Buffalo Bill is coming to Manitowoc with his Wild West show
Pullman Doha West Bay Hotel opens in Qatar
DoubleTree by Hilton hotel opens in Malaysia
Great Dorset Chilli Festival, the hottest festival in UK
 

SEA, LAND, AIR

New Ford Maverick Tremor Off-Road Package revealed

Porsche unveils newest generation of 911 GT3 R
2023 Subaru Crosstrek sells like hotcakes
New Mercedes‑Benz GLC, at home on any terrain
GMC unleashes new 2023 Sierra 1500 AT4X AEV Edition
First BMW M3 Touring presented
 

DESIGN

Nobody's Child, everybody's favorite

Freddy WR.UP, pants that hug you in all the right places
Stylishly luxurious house design
Great design ideas that might not work for you
Garden mirrors, explore new views of your garden
Unusual and highly functional lamps
 

GADGETS

Pro-Ject X8 turntable, superior noise suppression and great sound

Shure MV7 professional dynamic microphone now available in new limited-edition color
Forget streaming services, use McIntosh MR89 to enjoy AM/FM music
Infinix NOTE 12 PRO, first smartphone powered by MediaTek Helio G99
MW75 active noise-cancelling headphones, variety of new features
Parasound JC 1+ mono power amplifier by John Curl, pure delight
 

HEALTH

Novartis says two children died after receiving gene therapy Zolgensma

FDA approves Roche's Xofluza to treat influenza in children aged 5 years and older
Toronto Public Health confirms first mosquitoes to test positive for West Nile virus in 2022
Menarini Group's Elacestrant granted priority review by FDA
UK launches vaccine booster campaign as polio spreads
New zoonotic virus Langya infects 35 people in China
 

MEANTIME

Swiss mountain pass ice to melt completely within weeks

ZOO gorillas invented new sound to communicate with humans
Trees store carbon even after harvested
Subsurface water on Mars defy expectations
First detection of gas in circumplanetary disk
Drought increases toxic microbe-laden dust landing in Sierras