POST Online Media Lite Edition



 

Toyota Motor Company to pay $180 million for decade-long noncompliance with Clean Air Act reporting

Christian Fernsby |
The United States has filed and simultaneously settled a civil lawsuit against Toyota Motor Corporation, Toyota Motor North America Inc., Toyota Motor Sales U.S.A. Inc., and Toyota Motor Engineering & Manufacturing North America Inc. (Toyota) for systematic, longstanding violations of Clean Air Act emission-related defect reporting requirements, which require manufacturers to report potential defects and recalls affecting vehicle components designed to control emissions.

Article continues below



Topics: TOYOTA   

Along with the civil complaint, the United States has filed a consent decree, agreed to by Toyota, that resolves the government’s complaint through Toyota’s payment of a $180 million civil penalty and the imposition of injunctive relief. The $180 million penalty is the largest civil penalty for violation of EPA’s emission-reporting requirements.

The injunctive provisions require Toyota to follow compliance and reporting practices designed to ensure timely investigation of emission-related defects and timely reporting to EPA, and include training, communication, and oversight requirements.

“For a decade, Toyota systematically violated regulations that provide EPA with a critical compliance tool to ensure that vehicles on the road comply with federal emissions standards,” said Audrey Strauss, Acting U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York.

“Toyota shut its eyes to the noncompliance, failing to provide proper training, attention, and oversight to its Clean Air Act reporting obligations. Toyota’s actions undermined EPA’s self-disclosure system and likely led to delayed or avoided emission-related recalls, resulting in financial benefit to Toyota and excess emissions of air pollutants.

Today, Toyota pays the price for its misconduct with a $180 million civil penalty and agreement to injunctive relief to ensure that its violations will not be repeated.”

During the period of noncompliance, Toyota managers and staff in Japan knew that Toyota was no longer even attempting to determine whether it was aware of 25 instances of the same emission-related defect in a model year – the threshold requirement for filing an EDIR. Rather than follow this legally required standard,

Toyota unilaterally decided to file EDIRs principally when Toyota was required to file distinct reports with California regulators under a less strict standard – a standard that EPA had rejected as too lenient when Toyota had previously proposed to rely on it for federal reporting.

Toyota managers and staff in Japan repeatedly identified the discrepancy between Toyota’s procedures and the plain language of the federal requirements but failed to bring Toyota into compliance.

As a result of its conduct, Toyota deprived EPA of timely information regarding emission-related defects and recalls and avoided the early focus on emission defects contemplated by the regulations.

Toyota’s conduct likely resulted in delayed or avoided recalls, with Toyota obtaining a significant economic benefit, pushing costs onto consumers, and lengthening the time that unrepaired vehicles with emission-related defects remained on the road.

Toyota admits, acknowledges, and accepts responsibility for what is included in the consent decree.

Between approximately 2005 and late 2015, Toyota routinely filed emission defect reports to EPA materially late and, in many cases, failed to file such reports at all until a self-disclosure of non-compliance in late 2015.

In March and May 2002, at EPA’s request, Toyota and EPA representatives met to discuss Toyota’s internal process for identifying whether 25 instances of a specific emission-related defect exist in vehicles or engines of the same model year, requiring an EDIR filing.

At a first meeting in March 2002, Toyota described its EDIR process in which Toyota would investigate whether it had 25 defects only upon receiving 25 “product reports” from its dealers, but would supplement that review by filing an EDIR upon receiving warranty claims for an emission-related part in 4 percent of Toyota’s California fleet (a threshold requiring a separate filing to state authorities under California law).

At the meeting, EPA rejected this EDIR process as not timely considering warranty claims, despite the incorporation of the 4 percent California trigger.

At a May 2002 meeting with EPA, Toyota presented its revised process.

Under that process, Toyota would commence an investigation to determine whether an EDIR filing was required when it had received warranty claims for an emission-related part for 1 percent of relevant vehicles nationwide; when it received 500 such warranty claims regardless of the percentage; or when it received 25 similar early warning reports.

Toyota noted internally that EPA seemed pleased with this approach, which EPA had described as “more stringent than California.” In 2003, 2004, and 2005, as part of an annual review, Toyota submitted its May 2002 process in writing to EPA as an overview of its EDIR reporting program.

Without notifying EPA, in approximately 2005, Toyota stopped following the May 2002 EDIR process. In approximately 2005, Toyota began filing EDIRs primarily when filing the California reports triggered by the 4 percent threshold. Toyota also filed EDIRs in a small number of instances when it was otherwise filing VERRs with EPA.

From approximately 2005 to 2015, Toyota stopped making any independent determination of whether 25 defects existed requiring an EDIR filing. Multiple times during this period, Toyota staff charged with preparing EDIRs identified that the plain language of the EDIR regulations called for filing an EDIR upon the identification of 25 defects, but that Toyota was not doing so. These staff did not cause Toyota to change its practice.

As a result of this conduct, Toyota filed at least 69 EDIRs materially late. Thirty-nine of these were filed materially late in the ordinary course of Toyota’s business. In late 2015, Toyota self-disclosed another 30 that had not been filed at all. Some EDIRs were ultimately filed as many as eight years after they were due.

Beyond EDIRs, Toyota also failed during this period to file 20 VERRs required for emission-related recall campaigns that it conducted and failed to file more than two hundred Quarterly Reports related to such campaigns.

Between 2005 and 2015, Toyota failed to provide its employees with adequate training, resources, or oversight to ensure that Toyota complied with its reporting obligations to EPA. As a result of Toyota’s conduct, EPA did not timely receive mandated information regarding emission-related defects and recalls.


What to read next

Justice Department reaches $3 million settlement with Nissan Motor
Toyota Korea fined $729,307 for false advertising
Dollar General, Dollar Tree, and Family Dollar to pay $1.2 million for selling expired products

Excessive rainfall and flooding threat in Puerto Rico and New Mexico

 
A trailing cold front in connection with a low pressure system currently moving east across the Great Lakes toward New England will bring a chance of rain into the eastern U.S. on this first day of November following an exceptionally dry October for this part of the country.
 
 

Latest

U.S. oil and gas rig count unchanged stays at 585
New Jersey Governor Murphy to lead economic mission to UK
Governor Moore commends launch of double-stack rail operations at Port of Baltimore
MEPPI will create at least 200 new jobs in Southwestern Pennsylvania

NEWS

Record heat in southern U.S.

Peru's ex-president Alejandro Toledo sentenced to 20 years in prison over corruption
U.S. weather: Dry in east; active pattern for west
Finland wins European Transport Safety Council’s road safety prize for 2024
Maritime crime and piracy incidents lowest since 1994
Bulgaria: EPPO accuses former mayor and ex-governor in investigation into fishing port in Varna
 

BUSINESS

Iran lifts ban on brand-new Apple phones import

Istanbul provides free public transport for unemployed residents
EIB backs Gran Canaria with €300 million loan for Salto de Chira hydroelectric project
New Zealand concludes high quality trade deal with Gulf Cooperation Council
African Development Bank approves $54 million loan for Mozambique’s first wind energy project
U.S. oil and gas rig count steady
 

Trending Now

Istanbul provides free public transport for unemployed residents

EIB backs Gran Canaria with €300 million loan for Salto de Chira hydroelectric project

Iran lifts ban on brand-new Apple phones import

Indonesia bans sales of Google's Pixel smartphones


POLITICS

Indonesia bans sales of Google's Pixel smartphones

UK Government ends miners’ pension injustice
Governor Pillen joins letter requesting Biden take action dealing with IV fluid shortage
Canada reduces credit card fees by 27 pct for small businesses
Zambia, China sign MoU to establish African nation's first cholera vaccine plant
Turkey imposes anti-dumping duties on steel imports from China, Russia, India, Japan
 

Today We Recommend

UK Government ends miners’ pension injustice


Highlights 

MEPPI will create at least 200 new jobs in Southwestern Pennsylvania

Solarcycle will create 640 new full-time jobs in Polk County, Georgia

Pennsylvania: GSK will create at least 200 new, high-paying jobs in Lancaster County


COMPANIES

Solarcycle will create 640 new full-time jobs in Polk County, Georgia

Polish Laude Smart Intermodal to build rail terminal in Ukraine
Pennsylvania: GSK will create at least 200 new, high-paying jobs in Lancaster County
Hemlock Semiconductor creating over 1,000 manufacturing and construction jobs in Michigan
Evergy to invest more than $2B in two new high-efficiency natural gas plants in Kansas
New AIG office hub to create 600 Metro Atlanta jobs
 

CAREERS

Stellantis leverages its management organisation

African Development Bank appoints director general for East Africa
Mars announces new leadership within its petcare business
OCI Global announces leadership changes
Ethypharm appoints Éric Chevalier as group human resources director
Exothera appoints Cedric Volanti as CEO
 

ECONOMY

Fraser Institute: Canada’s debt ranking falls from best in G7 to 7th worst

Kuwait reports $5.2 bln budget deficit in FY 2023-24
Eurozone reports modest Q1 GDP growth, stable annual inflation
Italy sees faster economic growth in Q1
Slovenia's economy expected to grow 0.9 pct in Q1
Italy faces deficit infringement procedure
 

EARNINGS

Ericsson Q2 sales down but North America up

Lockton revenue $3.55 billion
Motorcar Parts of America Q4 sales $189.5 million
Limoneira Q2 revenue $44.6 million
Lululemon athletica Q1 revenue increased 10% to $2.2 billion
PVH Q1 GAAP EBIT $205 million
 

OP-ED

Micromanaging is the worst enemy of efficiency and teamwork

Niger set to monetize massive gas reserves through Saharan natural gas pipeline
Putting the brakes on EV folly that choked the market
Oil discovery in Kavango Basin may mean huge benefits for Namibians
Cape Town and Dubai battle over Africa's energy future
Is America going to lose its superpower status?
 

AGRIFISH

U.S. confirms H5N1 bird flu in swine for first time

Bluetongue outbreaks escalate in Czech Republic
French farmers to resume nationwide protests in November
Greece on alert after outbreak of sheep pox
Argentina opened South African market to send porcine hemoglobin powder
Hong Kong suspends import of poultry meat and products from Canyon County, Idaho
 

LEADERSHIP

Employers prefer younger job candidates for AI roles although experienced workers perform same or better

Study finds workers misjudge wage markets
Some organizations may need to expand their hierarchical structures earlier than others
Study finds there's right way and wrong way to deliver negative feedback in workplace
Allyship is critical and its needs appreciation
Generating 'buzz' about new products can influence their success
 

CRIME

BHP, Vale agree to pay $30B damages for Brazil dam disaster

Commission fines České dráhy and Österreichische Bundesbahnen €48.7 million over collusion to exclude common compe
SEC charges Keurig with making inaccurate statements regarding recyclability of K-Cup beverage pod
SEC charges John Deere with FCPA violations for subsidiary’s role in Thai bribery scheme
AG Bonta secures $3.9 million settlement with cryptocurrency company Robinhood
Italy issues $6.4 million fine over Chinese cars badged as Italian
 

Magazine

TRAVEL

Radisson Hotel Group debuts in the heart of Tunisia’s capital city, Tunis

Morocco’s first Radisson branded hotel opens in Casablanca
Buna channels, an unreal and beautiful part of Bosnia and Herzegovina
JW Marriott unveils Mindful Haven with opening of JW Marriott Hotel Nairobi
Sotheby's Sports Week returns with fantastic artifacts
Red Roof properties open in Michigan
 

SEA, LAND, AIR

Citroën C3 Aircross, the most affordable compact SUV with 7 seats

2025 Chevrolet Equinox stands apart with fresh looks and capability
Hill Helicopters HX50, luxury in the sky
Opel Movano becomes fully equipped camper van
Porsche Panamera, new hybrid variants
Dodge Charger, 670 horsepower of electric
 

DESIGN

Cold night, hot fire pit, cool entertainment

Embellish your home with PVC panels
You'll have to hurry if you want one of 20 new Louis Vuitton watches
Luxury duvet looks good, fells good and keeps you healthy
Vacheron Constantin, watches for life and more
Schüller kitchens, where functionality marries design
 

GADGETS

MESA/Boogie Celebrates 40-year partnership with John Petrucci

reMarkable 2, monochrome tablet for your thoughts and your eyes
OnePlus Ace 3V, first with Snapdragon 7 Plus Gen 3
ASUS Zenfone 11 Ultra, flagship with a reason
Samsung Galaxy S24 is photography powerhouse
Casette tapes are making a big comeback, and so are portable players
 

HEALTH

One more barrier to developing vaccine for HIV removed

Rwanda begins world's first clinical trial for treatment of Marburg virus disease
Rwanda restricts gatherings amid Marburg virus outbreak, to begin trials of vaccine
Teksas Attorney General reaches settlement in first-of-its-kind healthcare generative AI investigation
Potentially deadly fungal disease spreading in California
First mpox vaccines arrive in Africa
 

MEANTIME

Einstein Telescope step closer

Exoplanet-hunting telescope to begin search for another Earth in 2026
India to build first phase of its own space station by 2028
Roscosmos chief approves schedule of creating Russian orbital station through 2033
Potentially habitable 'exo-Venus' with Earth-like temperature discovered
Rare species of wild bees discovered in Berlin