POST Online Media Lite Edition



 

'Employee of the Month' is not a good thing, especially in Asia

Christian Fernsby |
Far from keeping up the good work, recipients of internal symbolic awards such as employee of the month or merit certificates perform worse after receiving the accolades, according to a recent international study published in Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes.

Article continues below




It's not always that awardees lose the drive to perform after proving their worth, says co-author Runjing Lu, a finance professor in the Alberta School of Business. In many cases, coworkers will subsequently undermine the winners' success.

"There have been a handful of papers published on the negative effects of symbolic awards, but they all focus on how the awards affect the participants' own behavior and motivation," notes Lu.

"We found it's not just the awardees themselves who are affected; there could also be a kind of social sabotage going on."

Lu defines a symbolic award as "a special type of non-monetary incentive whose value resides primarily in the public recognition of recipients."

Monetary rewards have long been regarded as problematic, she says, because they can provoke jealousy, resentment and other "corrosive" effects among employees. Symbolic awards had been considered a promising alternative.

But the findings by Lu and co-author Teng Li of Sun Yat-sen University point to a darker side of human nature. Especially in competitive workplaces with limited resources, internal symbolic award winners tend to become targets of subversion, she says.

In surveys of symbolic award recipients in this study, many said social undermining tends to be more passive; coworkers simply withdraw offers of help. But in some cases coworkers will go further, even poaching customers from award recipients involved in sales.

Previous research has shown that symbolic awards hamper performance mainly because recipients feel they've reached the required bar and no longer need to expend the same effort, says Lu.

One study, for example, revealed that students recognized for perfect attendance were subsequently absent more often from school. Another showed that winners of the Fields Medal—one of the world's highest honors for mathematicians—published fewer academic papers after receiving the prize. And firms whose CEOs received awards had worse stock and operating performance in their wake.

What the new study reveals, however, are the interpersonal factors that can aggravate a decline in performance.

"It's not that symbolic awards are always bad," says Lu. "They can work well in situations where the competition is not that intense—where your success doesn't depend on my failure.

"But in organizations where resources are limited, singling you out as a top performer signals to coworkers to compete for your resources. They have strong incentives to push you down."

Cultural context also matters, she says. The study examined a large branch of a leading insurance firm in China and found that social undermining of award recipients was more pronounced than typically documented in the West, potentially due to an emphasis on group harmony as opposed to individual achievement in Asian culture.

"Participants from Asian collectivist cultures exhibited a higher preference for high achievers to fail than those from individualistic cultures," says Lu. "In a collective culture, you don't want to stand out."


$18.6 million investment for three bridge replacement projects on Thruway in Central New York completed

 
Governor Kathy Hochul announced the completion of an $18.6 million investment for three separate bridge replacement projects on the Thruway in Central New York.
 
 

Latest

After fatal crash, Japan to ground Osprey aircraft, asks U.S. to follow suit
Vietnam's trade surplus reaches 25.83 bln USD in 11 months
3 tonnes of cocaine seized off Senegal's Dakar coast
Value of cereal production in EU €64.4 billion, milk value €58.0 billion

NEWS

Romania: EPPO carries out searches in probe into misuse of funds for Roma communities

Poland filed complaint against Germany regarding illegal storage of waste
RMT calls for end to cuts as London’s tube crime soars
Prosecutor's Office will investigate accident in Polish coal mine
Henry Kissinger dies at age 100
Report on marine casualty involving cruise ship Viking Polaris south-east of Cape Horn
 

BUSINESS

Bulgaria plagued by shortage of medical professionals

Kenya: African Development Bank commits more than €101 million to boost access to electricity
Europe’s critical infrastructure faces growing threat from extreme rainfall events
Technical capacity of Balticconnector interconnection point will be increased
Almost 600 migrants arrive on Italy's Lampedusa island
REFORMERS project launches Europe’s first Renewable Energy Valley in Netherlands
 

Trending Now

Romania: EPPO carries out searches in probe into misuse of funds for Roma communities

New York: $100 million for zero-emission school buses

Dr. Martens H1 revenue decreased by 5%

Kenya: African Development Bank commits more than €101 million to boost access to electricity


POLITICS

New York: $100 million for zero-emission school buses

Poland to seek return of EU permits for Ukrainian haulers
EU Solidarity Fund grants €100 million of advance payment to Slovenia following summer floods
Bolivia gets green light for full Mercosur membership
Canada signs deal to refurbish nuclear reactor in Romania
Gas flow agreement to bolster energy security in Italy and Switzerland
 

Today We Recommend

Argentina records hundreds of Trichinella cases


Highlights 

Novo Nordisk invests 2.1 billion euros in expansion in Chartres, France creates 500+ new jobs

Boehringer Ingelheim to acquire T3 Pharmaceuticals in deal worth over $500m

Chinese MMG will acquire Botswana copper company for $1.88bn


COMPANIES

Impala Platinum restarts South African mines after deadly accident

Offshore Odfjell drillers strike pay deal
Unite announces rolling Chivas Brothers strike action across Scotland
Unite brands Barclays disgraceful as it announces job losses before Christmas
Port of Rotterdam Authority officially commissions Container Exchange Route
Commission approves €833 million Danish and Swedish State aid measure to recapitalise SAS
 

CAREERS

Pyxis Oncology appoints Ken Kobayashi as chief medical officer

Amylyx Pharmaceuticals appoints Camille L. Bedrosian as chief medical officer
Federal Signal Corporation appoints Katrina L. Helmkamp to board
First Resource Bancorp appoints Kristen Fries as CFO
Network International appoints Mpho Sadiki as group managing director, merchant solutions for Africa
Liquid Intelligent Technologies: Oswald Jumira new CEO of Liquid C2 business unit
 

ECONOMY

French economy contracts in Q3

Sweden enters recession with GDP shrinking 0.3 pct in Q3
Türkiye GDP grew 5.9% in Q3
Australian inflation falls to 4.9 pct
Bankruptcies soar among German large companies
Mexico's economy sees 3.3 pct growth in Q3
 

EARNINGS

Dr. Martens H1 revenue decreased by 5%

Fortaco H1 sales EUR 79.9 million
Seadrill Q3 revenues $414 million
LightInTheBox Q3 revenues increased by 27.5%
Natuzzi Q3 revenue €74.9 million
Foot Locker Q3 sales decreased by 8.6%
 

OP-ED

Micromanaging is the worst enemy of efficiency and teamwork

Niger set to monetize massive gas reserves through Saharan natural gas pipeline
Putting the brakes on EV folly that choked the market
Oil discovery in Kavango Basin may mean huge benefits for Namibians
Cape Town and Dubai battle over Africa's energy future
Is America going to lose its superpower status?
 

AGRIFISH

Rosselkhoznadzor begins inspections of Brazilian poultry meat producers

Kazakhstan will supply peaches, cherries, and plums to China
Poland to start exporting apples to Indonesia
Vietnam becomes world's second shrimp supplier
Japan confirms season's second bird flu outbreak
France reports bird flu on turkey farm as disease spreads in Europe
 

LEADERSHIP

LinkedIn can trigger feelings of imposter syndrome

Study suggests corporate culture thwarts efforts to hire innovative candidates
Workplace wellness policies could soften effects of workaholism
Customers willing to wait longer for delivery when they shop in store showroom
Internal crowdfunding fosters innovation and engages employees
Employee owned businesses deliver an 8 to 12% productivity boost
 

CRIME

BNP Paribas subsidiary fined maximum amount over Swiss franc loans

Commission fines Rabobank €26.6 million over Euro-denominated bonds trading cartel
Shell Energy fined £1.4m by Ofcom for consumer protection breaches
Italy's antitrust agency fines energy companies for aggressive billing
New Jersey duo defrauded investors and mortgage lenders through $2.5 million investment scam
SEC charges Royal Bank of Canada with internal accounting controls violations
 

Magazine

TRAVEL

Mushrooms of all kinds will be featured at Autumn Bio Festival in Portugal

Festive winter fun in and around Hannover
Premier Australian motoring event returns this weekend
Yummy cake and bake show in London with great prizes
Tuileries Garden Christmas, magic of Christmas in Paris
Museum of the Moon to welcome all science fans in Larnaca
 

SEA, LAND, AIR

Chevrolet Tahoe and Suburban come with new look

Chinese HiPhi revealed electric sedan, too bad it can't be trusted
New 2025 Ram 1500, Hurricane 3L and 420 horsepower
Gulfstream G700 business jet to fly 14,353 kilometers
Beneteau First, slender mainsail and generously sized foresails
Porsche launches speedboat with 400 kW
 

DESIGN

Hollywood Regency, the style that's always in

Filippo Loreti, premium Italian timepieces for adventurous gentlemen
Creative furniture that redefines the meaning of sofa
Perfect ovens for perfect pizza at home
Designer radiators, focal point that heats your room
What to do and what not to do when designing your living room
 

GADGETS

Motorola g family smartphones bring something for everyone

Focal Shape 65 monitor, loudspeakers for home or professional studio
NAD C 268 stereo power amplifier, multipurpose workhorse
DeVore Fidelity Orangutan O/Reference, €90,000 for ultimate sound
Motorola razr, foldable phone that allows you to live your real life
Rogers 65V-1 integrated amplifier delivers remarkable sound made in America
 

HEALTH

Argentina records hundreds of Trichinella cases

Loss of auditory nerve fibers uncovered in individuals with tinnitus
Netherlands sees alarming surge in pneumonia among children, China disinfecting schools
Pocket sized DNA sequencers track malaria drug resistance in Ghana in near real time
Novavax's updated COVID-19 vaccine now option for all 194 WHO member states
Japan trials over the counter sales of 'morning after' pill
 

MEANTIME

Astronomers spot giant stream of stars between galaxies

Six exoplanets discovered in synchronised dance
Earth braces for geomagnetic storm on November 30 after two powerful solar flares
Frozen food temperatures changed by just three degrees to save CO2 emissions
Groundbreaking method to match celestial objects across telescopes
Moscow Veterinary Academy celebrates birthday of Russia’s first puppy born to surrogate mother dog