POST Online Media Lite Edition


Men are harder competitors, women are more realistic

Christian Fernsby |
In competition situations, men invest more resources than women in reducing the performance of competitors. Men overestimate sabotage against them and respond accordingly, while women assess the sabotage efforts of competitors realistically, according to a laboratory experiment carried out at KIT.

Article continues below

A work environment that creates transparency and reduces uncertainty about the sabotage level of competitors, hence, causes men to sabotage less, reports the research team from Karlsruhe and Bonn in the Experimental Economics journal.

The prospect of a bonus, project or promotion may be an incentive to work hard—or to make the performance of colleagues look bad. To achieve this, competitors are deprived of important information about customers or business partners, they are not informed about meeting dates, or data is deleted.

Professor Petra Nieken, who holds the Chair for Human Resource Management at Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT), studies incentive and motivation mechanisms. Together with Dr. Simon Dato, scientist at the Institute for Applied Microeconomics of Bonn University, she studied differences in conduct of men and women in competition.

"We wanted to clearly show the gender difference in unethical conduct, i.e. sabotage, and understand the underlying mechanisms in order to develop countermeasures in the long term," says the economist.

The results of her controlled laboratory experiment are published under the title "Gender Difference in Sabotage: The Role of Uncertainty and Beliefs" in the Experimental Economics journal.

In competitions, it is the relative performance that counts. It is only important to be better than the competitors. "Either you work harder to increase your performance or you reduce the performance of your opponent. All activities to reduce performance of others are referred to as sabotage," Nieken explains.

In the experiment, the participants were told to encode words by a sequence of numbers. For each correct coding, they were given points and the person scoring most points received a bonus. On average, women and men showed a similar performance. Both genders would thus have about the same chance to win the competition against each other.

In the experiment, however, they had the option to reduce the competitor's scores by the use of money. Men turned out to sabotage more than women. They invested more money in reducing the performance of the competitor. "For this reason, they win more often, although men and women reach the same performance on the average," Nieken says.

Moreover, the information given to the participants of the experiment about the sabotage level of their competitors was varied specifically.

"We found that the factor relevant to one's own sabotage behavior is the uncertainty about the sabotage level of the competitors," Nieken says. "Men systematically overestimate the sabotage level directed against them.

"For this reason, their own sabotage level also is higher. Women, by contrast, realistically assess the sabotage level. Women and men do not have different moral values, but men more strongly perceive their environment as competitive," Nieken points out.

When men are given the feedback that the world is not as competitive as they assume, they accordingly adjust their expectation and conduct and reduce their sabotage level to that of women.

"Even a very soft signal is sufficient," Nieken says. The consequence: Now, it is the better person that wins and women are not systematically disadvantaged. According to Nieken, this finding is the basis for counteracting sabotage by the company creating awareness of this mechanism. "It is the goal to promote the best. If the "wrong" person is promoted systematically, this is disadvantageous for both the losers and the company."

What to read next

Bigger number of women in financial markets could stabilize them
Shareholders rate women board members more highly than men
Women are choosing positions with less applicants

U.S.: Rain and higher elevation snow will continue

A deep upper-level trough will move onshore over most of the West Coast on Sunday, moving to the Upper Great Lakes to the Southern Rockies by Tuesday.


United flight from Chicago to Vegas makes emergency landing in Nebraska
Kerry pleads guilty and agrees to pay $19.228 million in connection with 2018 salmonella outbreak
Brazil sinks rusting old French aircraft carrier in Atlantic
China allowed truck entry on border with Tajikistan


U.S.: Rain and higher elevation snow will continue

United flight from Chicago to Vegas makes emergency landing in Nebraska
Brazil sinks rusting old French aircraft carrier in Atlantic
Egypt's former prime minister dies at 67
Longest-serving president of Pakistan Pervez Musharraf dies
5.5-magnitude earthquake hits northern Chile


South Africa to construct new power transmission lines in northern province

Spain suffers amid severe shortage of drugs
Free travel will be extended to even more of London’s lowest paid transport workers
North Adriatic Hydrogen Valley project receives 25 million in grants
Croatia to pay MOL $235 mln in settlement of arbitration case for INA
€25 million EBRD loan to support new tram line in Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina

Trending Now

110,000 more users affected in LG Uplus’ data breach

Egypt's former prime minister dies at 67

Viatel Technology to create 50 Irish tech jobs

Brazil sinks rusting old French aircraft carrier in Atlantic


India to ban hundreds of Chinese-linked betting and loan lending apps

UK and coalition partners announce price caps on Russian oil products
Fiji ends training and exchange agreement with China
France mulls extending nuclear reactors' lifespan
PM: Decisions by Commission for Emergency Situations help Moldova get out of winter with dignity
Denys Shmyhal: We expect duty-free trade with the EU to be extended until the end of 2024

Today We Recommend

Fiji ends training and exchange agreement with China


Viatel Technology to create 50 Irish tech jobs

Aon Q4 income decreased 24%

ASSA ABLOY Q4 sales increased by 28%


110,000 more users affected in LG Uplus’ data breach

Viatel Technology to create 50 Irish tech jobs
Ethiopian Airlines inaugurates second aviation academy campus in Hawassa
Statkraft and INEOS Inovyn sign new long-term green power agreements
Portugal's Parliament approves inquiry into TAP airline
Iberdrola launching new call for master's scholarships for Spain and UK


Satu Rautavalta appointed new CEO of Pimatic

Exothera appoints Darren Leva as chief business officer
Vesta taps Shimon Steinmetz as CFO
Bruno Ultra Barcelos appointed managing director of Ethypharm UK
Syntach names Patrick NJ Schnegelsberg as new CEO
Chiesi appoints Giuseppe Accogli as new group CEO


U.S. employment spikes in January, unemployment down

U.S. services PMI jumped
Türkiye inflation higher than expected at nearly 58%
West Virginia January revenue surplus continues to show opportunity for tax cuts is now
Indonesia: Inflation decelerates in January
Germany's foreign trade balance sees surplus of 10.0 billion euros in December 2022


United States Steel Q4 earnings $174 million

Skechers Q4 sales increased 13.5%
Bosch posts sales growth
Cigna income $6.7 billion
Aon Q4 income decreased 24%
ASSA ABLOY Q4 sales increased by 28%


Micromanaging is the worst enemy of efficiency and teamwork

Niger set to monetize massive gas reserves through Saharan natural gas pipeline
Putting the brakes on EV folly that choked the market
Oil discovery in Kavango Basin may mean huge benefits for Namibians
Cape Town and Dubai battle over Africa's energy future
Is America going to lose its superpower status?


Free practical forestry training courses available in UK

Hong Kong suspends import of poultry meat and products from Kagoshima Prefecture, Japan
Share of Russian agricultural exports to friendly countries grows to 82% in 2022
Ministry of Agriculture: Yangtze River fishing ban sees positive progress
Netherlands: Gross seed onion yield down 17.2 percent
Price growth led to record start for Norwegian seafood exports in 2023


Lucky CEO means bad luck for hiring company

Product images could boost food pantry use
The madness of fast service: I want it now!
How to build a resilient brand
Only 32% of employees believe their pay is fair
Corporate duty waivers limit organic company growth and innovation


Kerry pleads guilty and agrees to pay $19.228 million in connection with 2018 salmonella outbreak

UK: Serious Fraud Office secures three convictions in $500 million trade finance fraud
AG for District of Colubia: $1,950,000 available for eligible Drizly drivers as result of tip-theft investigation
North Carolina: 52 stores pay fines for price scanning errors in 33 counties
EAO issued third fine for Coastal GasLink project
Dutch central bank fines cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase 3.3 mln euros



Legend Rock Petroglyphs in Wyoming, history right in front of you

La Chandeleur in Paris: Crêpe Day for all of you
Tru by Hilton Monterrey Fundidora hotel opens in Mexico
IntercityHotel Berlin Airport BER opens
Art After School, the perfect way to spark imagination in your child
The world's biggest food fair in Berlin you don't wanna miss


2024 Range Rover Velar, pure greed and distraction

Honda Pilot TrailSport, fully equipped SUV with great ground clearance
2024 Corvette E-ray, electrified 4WD
Jaguar I-PACE is now more distinctive
2023 Toyota Prius expected this January
2023 Lincoln Corsair, advance features and ActiveGlide


Curved sofas, elegant and gentle

Solios watches, from nature to luxury
Coats of faux fur, but not of faux style
Redifining kitchen space and experience with workstations
Dinning sofas, a soft addition to a modern dinning table
Patchwork carpets, vintage Persian carpets made with unparalleled skill


Samsung Galaxy S23 smartphones, cameras with possibility to make calls

Harman Luxury Audio introduces new JBL Classic Series
KEF KC62, audio excellence and design ingenuity
Panasonic announces flagship OLED TV MZ2000
McIntosh MC451, 150 Watt vacuum tube and 300 Watt solid state amplifier
Headonia 2A3, luxury headphone amplifier that comes with gloves


Urinary incontinence, a condition that shouldn't be embarrassing

Synthetic opioids will be banned as UK government acts to stop drug deaths
Japan gives priority review status to Alzheimer's drug developed by Eisai, Biogen
Working group proposes on how to make Finland tobacco-free by 2030
Study: Merck COVID-19 pill linked to virus mutations
South Africa authorises roll out of COVID-19 boosters to fight Omicron variant


Astronomers observe light bending around an isolated white dwarf

Webb telescope catches early galaxy formation in action
Straigh and gay men both prefer masculine men for important jobs
Green comet to visit Earth after 50,000 years
Astronomers captured spectacular, ongoing collision between at least three galaxy clusters
NASA system predicts small asteroid to pass close by Earth this week