POST Online Media Lite Edition



 

Commission approves several French measures in favour of Beauvais and La Rochelle airports

Christian Fernsby |
The European Commission has on July 26 approved under EU State aid rules several French aid measures granted between 2001 and 2012 in favour of the French airports of Beauvais and La Rochelle.

Article continues below




However, in the case of La Rochelle airport, the Commission found that Ryanair and Jet2 had received State aid incompatible with EU rules.

France must now recover from Ryanair and Jet2 the unlawful State aid amounting to approximately EUR 8.4 million and EUR 81 000 respectively.

On 30 May 2012 the Commission opened an in-depth investigation to assess whether financial arrangements between the French public authorities and Beauvais airport, as well as rebates and marketing agreements concluded between this airport and its customer airlines, were in line with EU State aid rules.

Between 2001 and 2012, the French regional and local authorities granted investment subsidies (in the form of three investment programmes for the modernisation and construction of infrastructure at Beauvais airport) and operating subsidies (in the form of direct grants, cash advances and partial coverage of the cost of promoting tourism) to the operators of Beauvais airport.

The Commission assessed the measures under Article 107(3)(c) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) and the Commission's Guidelines on State aid to airports and airlines.

The Commission considered that part of these subsidies – one of the three investment programmes, the operating subsidies, part of the cash advances and partial coverage of the cost of implementing a tourism development plan – did not constitute State aid, particularly in so far as this expenditure related to non-economic activities (for example airport security) and therefore did not fall within the scope of EU law on State aid.

The other part of the subsidies – i.e. the other two investment programmes and part of the cash advances – did constitute State aid, but the Commission concluded that these measures were compatible with the rules on State aid to airports and airlines.

In its assessment, the Commission took into account, inter alia, the fact that the aid was particularly necessary and proportionate to facilitate the economic development of Beauvais airport, and did not significantly distort competition with other airports in the Union, including the neighbouring Paris airports of Roissy and Orly.

Finally, the Commission considered that none of the airport services agreements concluded between Beauvais airport and a dozen or so airlines constituted State aid, since the contractual conditions did not go beyond what a profit-driven airport operator would have been prepared to offer in the same circumstances as the operators of Beauvais airport.

La Rochelle Airport

On 8 February 2012 the Commission opened an in-depth investigation to assess whether financial arrangements between the French public authorities and the airport of La Rochelle, as well as rebates and marketing agreements concluded between this airport and some of the airlines using it, were in line with EU State aid rules.

Between 2001 and 2012, the French regional and local authorities concluded several financial agreements with La Rochelle airport. The Commission assessed the measures under Article 107(3)(c) TFEU and the Commission's Guidelines on State aid to airports and airlines.

The Commission took the view that some of these measures did not constitute State aid. As regards the alleged under-invoicing of the services provided by the general section of the Chamber of Commerce and Industry (CCI) of La Rochelle to its airport service from 2006 to 2012, and the alleged over-invoicing of the services provided by La Rochelle airport to the public manager of Rochefort airport, the Commission concluded that this expenditure did not confer an economic advantage on La Rochelle airport because it was based on market prices.

As regards the subsidies granted by the French State to cover the ‘sovereign' tasks of La Rochelle airport, the Commission considered that they were linked to the exercise of non-economic activities (for example activities relating to the security of the airport) and therefore did not fall within the scope of EU law on State aid.

The other measures — the repayable advances granted by the general section of the La Rochelle CCI to the airport, the under-invoicing of the services provided by the general section of the La Rochelle CCI to the airport between 2001 and 2005, the financial contributions granted by the French local authorities towards promotion campaigns, and the equipment subsidies granted by the French local authorities – did indeed constitute State aid, but the Commission considered them to be compatible with the rules applicable to State aid to airports and airlines.

In its assessment, the Commission took into account, inter alia, the fact that the aid was particularly necessary and proportionate to facilitate the economic development of La Rochelle airport, and did not significantly distort competition with other airports in the Union, including the neighbouring airports of Angoulême, Rochefort and Niort.

However, the Commission considered that several airport services agreements and marketing services agreements concluded by La Rochelle airport between 2003 and 2010 with Ryanair and Jet2 did constitute incompatible State aid.

The Commission's investigation showed that these agreements conferred an unjustified economic advantage on Ryanair and Jet2 over their competitors, in that a profit-driven airport operator would never have agreed to grant similar conditions to those airlines in the same circumstances.

As this aid is considered incompatible, France must now recover the unlawful State aid from Ryanair and Jet2 amounting to approximately EUR 8.4 million and EUR 81 000 respectively.


What to read next

Commission approves €133 million to SATA airline, opens investigation into other support
Federal funds available for converting airports from military to civil and joint use airports
Commission asks European Court of Justice for penalties against Poland on activity of Disciplinary Chamber

U.S. bans Huawei, ZTE equipment over security risk

 
The Biden administration has banned approvals of new telecommunications equipment from China's Huawei Technologies and ZTE because they pose "an unacceptable risk" to U.S. national security.
 
 

Latest

Patchwork carpets, vintage Persian carpets made with unparalleled skill
Protests erupt in Xinjiang and Beijing against COVID-19 lockdowns
U.S.: Several regions face rainy, snowy weather
At least eight people dead in landslide in Italy

NEWS

Brazilian police launches operation against theft in containers at Port of Mucuripe/CE

Federal Police of Brazil launches operation to combat illegal sand extraction
U.S.: Heavy rainfall over south Texas, Santa Ana winds in southern California
Scotland agrees deal to avert Christmas rail strikes, begins talks with nurses
South Korean president warns to use special powers to end truckers' strike
British nurses to stage first strikes on December 15, 20
 

BUSINESS

Hengqin Line's landmark undersea tunnel connects Guangdong, Macao

EirGrid and RTE sign technical and financial agreements for Celtic Interconnector
Zuunbayan-Khangi railway set to deliver major boost to Mongolian exports and economy
Europe pours billions into Serbian Belgrade-Niš rail line
UK highways projects costing billions more than planned
UK car production returns to growth in October
 

Trending Now

Zuunbayan-Khangi railway set to deliver major boost to Mongolian exports and economy

EirGrid and RTE sign technical and financial agreements for Celtic Interconnector

U.S. bans Huawei, ZTE equipment over security risk

Ukraine fines Engie, Shell subsidiaries over Nord Stream 2


POLITICS

U.S. excludes oil for Japan from Russia's Sakhalin-2 from price cap

$15 million fast-tracked to fix roads in central and western NSW
New York Governor: Shop locally on Small Business Saturday
New York: More than $68m for 74 projects through Regional Economic Development Council initiative
Minister Ng launches exploratory talks toward free trade agreement between Canada and Ecuador
Council agrees on substance of new measures on joint purchases of gas and solidarity mechanism
 

Today We Recommend

UK highways projects costing billions more than planned


Highlights 

BMW invests EUR2 billion in Hungarian plant, will create 500+ jobs

Veon to unload Russian operations for $2.1 billion

SSE to sell 25% stake in transmission network arm for £1.5bn


COMPANIES

Commission clears ALD's acquisition of LeasePlan, subject to conditions

BMW invests EUR2 billion in Hungarian plant, will create 500+ jobs
Phantom Space gets four new NASA task orders
Gascade completes first LNG link to German gas network
Veon to unload Russian operations for $2.1 billion
Amazon workers called to strike across globe on Black Friday
 

CAREERS

1NCE expands leadership team in Europe and Asia-Pacific

Walt Disney fires CEO Bob Chapek, returns Robert A. Iger
Appian appoints Silvio Lima as head of corporate affairs
Appia Rare Earths appoints Irvine R. Annesley as vice president
Charwood Energy appoints Pierre-Yves Lefebvre as CFO
Moon Surgical appoints Mark Toland as director
 

ECONOMY

Abu Dhabi GDP expands 11.2pc in H1 on robust non-oil activities

German economy grows more than initially estimated in Q3
Poland: Retail sales record slowest growth since February in October
Russia: Decline in industrial activity softens in October
Argentina: Merchandise exports decline in October
Argentina: Economic activity growth drops to six-month low in September
 

EARNINGS

G. Willi-Food Q3 sales increased by 16.6%

Deere Q4 net income $2.246 billion
Nordstrom Q3 net loss $20 million
VMware Q3 revenue $3.21 billion
Guess? Q3 net earnings down 26.9%
HP Inc. GAAP diluted net EPS down significantly, to eliminate between 4,000 and 6,000 jobs
 

OP-ED

Micromanaging is the worst enemy of efficiency and teamwork

Niger set to monetize massive gas reserves through Saharan natural gas pipeline
Putting the brakes on EV folly that choked the market
Oil discovery in Kavango Basin may mean huge benefits for Namibians
Cape Town and Dubai battle over Africa's energy future
Is America going to lose its superpower status?
 

AGRIFISH

Bulgaria and Germany will receive substantial funding from EU for maritime affairs, fisheries, aquaculture by 2027

Authorities introduce Swiss-wide anti-bird flu measures
Ghana: African Development Fund approves $27.9m grant for Savannah Agriculture Value Chain Development Project
Maine delegation and Governor Mills urge national retailers to continue selling Maine lobster
Uruguay will be able to export sorghum to China for human and animal consumption
Hong Kong suspends import of poultry meat and products from areas in Ireland, France and Japan
 

LEADERSHIP

Women buy from women, men buy from women and men

How employee opinion impacts CEO dismissal
Keeping it in family can be good news when it comes to CEOs
Over a third of office workers are hybrid 'misfits'
Proxy advisers have inherent incentive to create controversy, study shows
Established employees need adjustment period with new work colleagues
 

CRIME

Ukraine fines Engie, Shell subsidiaries over Nord Stream 2

New Zealand fines Southland fishing company $40,000
Italy's antitrust fines Edison Energia 3.8 mln euros over unfair practices
FTC secures monetary judgment in deceptive energy savings claims case
Croatian Competition Agency fines dairy processing company PIK Rijeka $13,740 for imposing unfair trading practices
SEC charges S&P Global Ratings with conflict of interest violations
 

Magazine

TRAVEL

Candlewood Suites Hotel opens in Aberdeen, Md.

Mount Roraima, Venezuela, 7,671 feet above the forest floor
Llao Llao Resort, an exclusive resort in the middle of nowhere
Abu Dhabi welcomes visitors to discover experiences at their own pace
Christmas Nights of Lights started in Indiana
Okinawa International Carnival, a parade of unique foreigners groups
 

SEA, LAND, AIR

New colorful Porsche 718 Style Edition models

2023 Toyota Prius Prime, solar panel roof and reliability
Volvo EX90, a car with updates
Cessna Citation CJ4 Gen2 jet, pursue your business goals while enjoying journey
GMC first Sierra EV marks turning point
BMW M2, fast beast in small package
 

DESIGN

Real life wallpapers, perfectly executed

A. Lange & Söhne, men's watches with true Saxonian DNA
Nella Vetrina, luxurious Italian designers bathroom vanities and furniture
Karastan rugs, durable and beautiful
Leather bags for every occasion and every life style
A walk in closet, the crown jewel of the bedroom
 

GADGETS

Take Elektor Fortissimo and make your own high-end amplifier

RangeXTD, a Wi-Fi extender that actually works
Monitor II A.N.C. headphones, iconic Marshall sound
Zebra TC15, a clever mix of a mobile phone and a computer for business use
Bathroom speakers will make your relaxing even better
NAD 399 amplifier, highly efficient and remarkably powerful
 

HEALTH

Ibuprofen and similar NSAIDS can be associated with hastened progression of osteoarthritis symptoms

Virgin Islands community encouraged to prevent antimicrobial resistance
Shionogi seeks Japan approval for COVID-19 vaccine
French doctors warn of antibiotics shortage
Merck's Keytruda shows survival benefit, meets main goal of gastric cancer trial
UK about fake vape factories: Consumers would be horrified if they saw the conditions in Chinese factories
 

MEANTIME

New European supercomputer inaugurated in Italy

European Space Agency presents new generation of astronauts
NASA selects Rocket Lab to launch TROPICS mission
World's heaviest flying bird heals itself with plants used in traditional medicine
James Webb Space Telescope reveals an exoplanet atmosphere as never seen before
U.S. to demolish four dams in river restoration effort