POST Online Media Lite Edition



 

FTC sues pesticide Syngenta and Corteva for price-fixing

Christian Fernsby |
FTC and state partners sue pesticide giants Syngenta and Corteva for using illegal pay-to-block scheme to inflate prices for farmers.

Article continues below




The Federal Trade Commission and a bipartisan coalition of 10 state attorneys general have filed a complaint in federal court against pesticide manufacturers Syngenta Crop Protection and Corteva, Inc. for allegedly paying distributors to block competitors from selling their cheaper generic products to farmers.

The complaint alleges that these big pesticide firms run so-called “loyalty programs” in which distributors only get paid if they limit business with competing manufacturers. Cutting off competition has allowed the defendants to inflate their prices and force American farmers to spend millions of dollars more for their products.

The complaint seeks to shut down this illegal pay-to-block scheme and restore competition to affected markets.

“The FTC is suing to stop Syngenta and Corteva from maintaining their monopolies through harmful tactics that have jacked up pesticide prices for farmers,” said FTC Chair Lina M. Khan.

“By paying off distributors to block generic producers from the market, these giants have deprived farmers of cheaper and more innovative options. Our lawsuit in partnership with a bipartisan state coalition makes clear that we are united in our fight to stop abusive monopolies from squeezing America’s farmers.”

Syngenta and Corteva are two of the largest pesticide manufacturers operating in the United States. Syngenta, based in Switzerland, is a subsidiary of a Chinese state-owned company. Corteva, headquartered in Indianapolis, is the successor to the agriscience businesses of DuPont and Dow Chemical Company, which merged in 2017.

The FTC complaint centers on the two firms’ efforts to artificially extend their patent monopolies.

When a company creates a new pesticide, it can patent that invention, preventing anyone else from selling it for 20 years. Ordinarily, when the patent expires, generic versions of the product enter the market to compete with the original brand-name version. The arrival of generics pushes prices down.

Instead of one company wielding a monopoly over a new product, many manufacturers can compete for farmers’ business.

Syngenta and Corteva, however, take illegal steps to stop generic pesticides from eating into their monopoly profits, the complaint alleges. The companies set up “loyalty” programs in which they make payments to distributors—as long as the distributors keep their purchases of competing generic pesticides beneath a very low threshold.

Under this scheme, Syngenta and Corteva make more money than they would if they had to compete fairly with generics. Boxing out the competition allows them to keep charging such high prices that, even after compensating the distributors, they can maintain a large profit margin. Distributors pass those high prices along to farmers.

And those prices are ultimately passed on to consumers.

The complaint details the defendants’ monopoly and market power, and the anticompetitive effects of their conduct, with respect to six particular crop-protection active ingredients.

Syngenta has monopoly and market power in the United States with respect to azoxystrobin, a fungicide; and mesotrione and metolachlor, both herbicides. Corteva, meanwhile, has monopoly and market power in the United States with respect to the herbicide rimsulfuron and the insecticide and nematicide oxamyl. Corteva also has market power with respect to the herbicide acetochlor.

The complaint was approved by a unanimous vote of 4-0-1, with Commissioner Noah Joshua Phillips recused. It alleges that the defendants violated federal antitrust law by using unfair methods of competition, unlawfully conditioning rebates on the exclusion of competitive products, unreasonably restraining trade, and unlawfully maintaining monopolies.

The defendants also violated state competition and consumer protection laws in California, Colorado, Illinois, Iowa, Indiana, Minnesota, Nebraska, Oregon, Texas, and Wisconsin, according to the complaint.

The complaint was joined by the attorneys general of California, Colorado, Illinois, Iowa, Indiana, Minnesota, Nebraska, Oregon, Texas, and Wisconsin.


What to read next

Tronox to vigorously fight FTC lawsuit against Cristal acquisition
Monsanto to Syngenta: We can get all regulatory approvals
Syngenta rejects $45 billion Monsanto takeover offer

Apollo Endosurgery to be acquired by Boston Scientific, enterprise value $615 million

 
Apollo Endosurgery announced it has entered into a definitive merger agreement to be acquired by Boston Scientific in an all-cash transaction with an enterprise value of approximately $615 million.
 
 

Latest

Poland: Criminal group extorted money making advantage of COVID situation
Sibanye-Stillwater begins construction of lithium hydroxide refinery in Finland
Switzerland's GDP grew by 0.2% in Q3 of 2022
Mexico's exports grow 19.5 pct

NEWS

UK: Christmas chaos ahead as Wiltshire parking wardens announce further strikes

Italy: 8 dead, several still missing after deadly Ischia mudslide
South Korea issues return-to-work order to truckers on strike
U.S.: Winter weather conditions for west, severe weather potential for south on Tuesday
World's largest volcano Mauna Loa erupts
WHO renames monkeypox as mpox on racism ground
 

BUSINESS

One in four U.S. workers still fear catching COVID at work, modest winter surge expected

No vessels left Ukrainian ports on November 28 due to adverse weather
Swedish nuclear reactor to be taken off-grid for repairs
UN and ILO must urgently intervene as South Korea weighs forcing striking drivers back to work, says ITF
More internationally educated family doctors on the way to British Columbia
Department of Health in South Africa to conduct feasibility study on implementing solar panels in hospitals
 

Trending Now

One in four U.S. workers still fear catching COVID at work, modest winter surge expected

Sibanye-Stillwater begins construction of lithium hydroxide refinery in Finland

Commission approves €557 million German support to compensate Deutsche Bahn

Apollo Endosurgery to be acquired by Boston Scientific, enterprise value $615 million


POLITICS

Tánaiste announces major change for small Irish companies

Commission approves €557 million German support to compensate Deutsche Bahn
Belgian government offers one-off tax-free bonus
Health minister discusses cooperation with French companies for manufacturing in Libya
Saudi Arabia unveils masterplan for mega Riyadh airport project
EU Parliament insists that EU must freeze funding to Hungary
 

Today We Recommend

One in four U.S. workers still fear catching COVID at work, modest winter surge expected


Highlights 

Apollo Endosurgery to be acquired by Boston Scientific, enterprise value $615 million

AstraZeneca to acquire Neogene Therapeutics for up to $320 mln

Shell to buy Nature Energy in £1.7bn deal


COMPANIES

Bechtel to build Intel's semiconductor manufacturing facilities in Ohio

Biocytogen Pharmaceuticals enters antibody agreement with ADC Therapeutics
BT announces plan for pay rise of up to 16% for all but highest paid
AstraZeneca to acquire Neogene Therapeutics for up to $320 mln
Shell to buy Nature Energy in £1.7bn deal
Africa Data Centres to build its first data centre in Kigali, Rwanda
 

CAREERS

US Foods appoints Dave Flitman as CEO

G Mining Ventures appoints Carlos Vilhena to board
Criterium Energy appoints David Dunlop as director
Arthex Biotech appoints Frédéric Legros as chairman
Promontory Therapeutics appoints Stanley J. Musial as CFO
1NCE expands leadership team in Europe and Asia-Pacific
 

ECONOMY

Trade between Bulgaria, North Macedonia to exceed EUR 1 Bln in 2022

EU trade with Indo-Pacific region
EU green energy product imports in 2021: 15.2 billion euros
Czech Republic: Economic sentiment ticks up in November
Poland: Business sentiment ticks up in November
Italy: Business confidence strengthens in November
 

EARNINGS

Natuzzi Q3 revenue increased 14.5%

CMA CGM Q3 revenue $19.9 billion
G. Willi-Food Q3 sales increased by 16.6%
Deere Q4 net income $2.246 billion
Nordstrom Q3 net loss $20 million
VMware Q3 revenue $3.21 billion
 

OP-ED

Micromanaging is the worst enemy of efficiency and teamwork

Niger set to monetize massive gas reserves through Saharan natural gas pipeline
Putting the brakes on EV folly that choked the market
Oil discovery in Kavango Basin may mean huge benefits for Namibians
Cape Town and Dubai battle over Africa's energy future
Is America going to lose its superpower status?
 

AGRIFISH

Colombian minister announces short and medium-term measures to help rural producers affected by winter weather

Third stage of vaccination against classical swine fever starts in Brazilian state Alagoas
Australia's fish stocks stable and steady
Australia pledges AUD 2 million to WTO Fisheries Funding Mechanism
Pesticide sales jump by 17% in Switzerland
Tesco announces close to £14 million of additional support for British egg industry
 

LEADERSHIP

Corporate duty waivers limit organic company growth and innovation

Women buy from women, men buy from women and men
How employee opinion impacts CEO dismissal
Keeping it in family can be good news when it comes to CEOs
Over a third of office workers are hybrid 'misfits'
Proxy advisers have inherent incentive to create controversy, study shows
 

CRIME

Meta Ireland fined 265 mln euros for data breach

Ukraine fines Engie, Shell subsidiaries over Nord Stream 2
New Zealand fines Southland fishing company $40,000
Italy's antitrust fines Edison Energia 3.8 mln euros over unfair practices
FTC secures monetary judgment in deceptive energy savings claims case
Croatian Competition Agency fines dairy processing company PIK Rijeka $13,740 for imposing unfair trading practices
 

Magazine

TRAVEL

Weather-resistant ArtWalk Downtown Billings, Montana

Dual branded Courtyard and Residence Inn by Marriott Hotel opens in Montreal
Candlewood Suites Hotel opens in Aberdeen, Md.
Mount Roraima, Venezuela, 7,671 feet above the forest floor
Llao Llao Resort, an exclusive resort in the middle of nowhere
Abu Dhabi welcomes visitors to discover experiences at their own pace
 

SEA, LAND, AIR

New colorful Porsche 718 Style Edition models

2023 Toyota Prius Prime, solar panel roof and reliability
Volvo EX90, a car with updates
Cessna Citation CJ4 Gen2 jet, pursue your business goals while enjoying journey
GMC first Sierra EV marks turning point
BMW M2, fast beast in small package
 

DESIGN

Patchwork carpets, vintage Persian carpets made with unparalleled skill

Real life wallpapers, perfectly executed
A. Lange & Söhne, men's watches with true Saxonian DNA
Nella Vetrina, luxurious Italian designers bathroom vanities and furniture
Karastan rugs, durable and beautiful
Leather bags for every occasion and every life style
 

GADGETS

Take Elektor Fortissimo and make your own high-end amplifier

RangeXTD, a Wi-Fi extender that actually works
Monitor II A.N.C. headphones, iconic Marshall sound
Zebra TC15, a clever mix of a mobile phone and a computer for business use
Bathroom speakers will make your relaxing even better
NAD 399 amplifier, highly efficient and remarkably powerful
 

HEALTH

Strong recommendation for pyronaridine-artesunate in revised WHO Malaria Treatment Guidelines

Pakistan launches anti-polio vaccination drive to inoculate 13.5 mln children
Ibuprofen and similar NSAIDS can be associated with hastened progression of osteoarthritis symptoms
Virgin Islands community encouraged to prevent antimicrobial resistance
Shionogi seeks Japan approval for COVID-19 vaccine
French doctors warn of antibiotics shortage
 

MEANTIME

Astrophysicists hunt for second-closest supermassive black hole

New European supercomputer inaugurated in Italy
European Space Agency presents new generation of astronauts
NASA selects Rocket Lab to launch TROPICS mission
World's heaviest flying bird heals itself with plants used in traditional medicine
James Webb Space Telescope reveals an exoplanet atmosphere as never seen before